Bybee: No Written Advice Provided to Any Agency Prior to August 1, 2002

 When Jay Bybee responded to written questions from Carl Levin about the torture authorizations in October 2008 (at a time when the Office of Professional Responsibility investigation was well-advanced, if not done), he made the following assertion.

While Judge Bybee said that he did not recall "any written advice provided to any governmental agency prior to August 1, 2002, on the meaning of the standards of conduct required for interrogation under the federal anti-torture statute or on specific interrogation methods," the August 1, 2002 memos were not the only occasion on which DOJ provided legal advice on the CIA’s interrogation program.

That’s interesting, because we know that on July 13, 2002, John Yoo wrote John Rizzo a letter in which he mapped out how to avoid prosecution for torture. He wrote:

This letter is in response to your inquiry at our meeting today [not attended by Bybee] about what is necessary to establish the crime of torture, as set forth in 18 USC 2340 et seq. The elements of the crime of torture are: (1) the torture occurred outside the United State; (2) the defendant acted under the color of law; (3) the victim was within the defendant’s custody or physical control; (4) the defendant specifically intended to cause severe mental or physical pain or suffering; and (5) the act inflicted severe mental or physical pain or suffering.

[snip]

Moreover, to establish that an individual has acted with the specific intent to inflict severe mental pain or suffering, an individual must act with specific intent, i.e., with the express purpose, [sic] of causing prolonged mental harm in order for the use of any of the predicate acts to constitute torture. Specific intent can be negated by a showing of good faith.

Now, it’s possible that Bybee did not consider this "written advice," but it sure seems to address the topic at hand (and note, Bybee did not say "opinion," but only "written advice"). It’s possible he lied–though I would imagine his answers to Levin very closely matched the answers he gave to OPR to what would presumably be remarkably similar questions.

Just as likely, I think Bybee may not have known about this letter.  On June 22, 2004, the day OLC withdrew the Bybee One memo, John Rizzo faxed the letter (including the fax cover sheet Yoo originally used) back to Daniel Levin. That either suggests Rizzo was trying to remind Levin of the meeting on July 13, 2002 (which Levin had attended as FBI Chief of Staff). Or he was providing OLC, where Levin had moved, with a copy of a letter that was not otherwise in their files.

This earlier letter lays out the torturer’s strategy for establishing a  "good faith" immunity from torture. Is it possible Bybee didn’t know about it?

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Reddit0Share on Facebook0Google+0Email to someone

62 Responses to Bybee: No Written Advice Provided to Any Agency Prior to August 1, 2002

Emptywheel Twitterverse
emptywheel My flight to PHL packed w/GR's Big Beer industry. You'll be happy to know we landed safely.
1mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz RT @hannahgais: @bmaz @ggreenwald oddly, this tweet about Snowden does a better job of describing Speechboy https://t.co/r6FpmZRvpb
19mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz Speechboy has an impeccable record of delivering the stupid https://t.co/L27CQWOs1P
22mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz RT @amilst44: Spot on article on the absurdity of Deflategate. https://t.co/N2K9igTdtU
50mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @stephanie_a517 they're like heeled sneakers. I'm not a heels person but these are comfy.
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @nickrmanes Wait are you at GRR right this second? I mean, I wasn't gonna stop in there but I blame you then.
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @stephanie_a517 Basically this: https://t.co/vbCbDQrXCd At GRR, which is quite a bit more...friendly than DTW, largely bc pipsqueak airport
3hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @markshefsiek And by "made" I obv mean refused to hide their crap. @0xcharlie @JZdziarski
3hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @markshefsiek The auto industry doesn't consider it theoretical. @0xcharlie made Chrysler do a recall. @JZdziarski
3hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel TSA lady was gonna let me thru w/my shoes on bc she has wanted a pair. She followed the roolz tho, and grilled me abt them after business.
3hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel RT @JZdziarski: How many of you can say “I nerded so hard, they passed laws with life in prison against what I do” @0xcharlie https://t.co/
3hreplyretweetfavorite
September 2009
S M T W T F S
« Aug   Oct »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930