As US-Iran Threat Exchange Continues, Pakistan Detains Three Iranian Border Guards

Iran and the US continued to exchange threats over the long holiday weekend. On Saturday night, Barack Obama signed the NDAA, which put into place the ability to enact strong sanctions on banking institutions involved in the sale of Iranian oil. Substantial flexibility is built into the legislation to allow the US to exempt various players in the oil market, so it is still quite uncertain how the sanctions will be implemented. As the video here shows, Iran also test-fired two types of missiles over the weekend prior to the ending of the ten days of naval war games. However, the threats have not ceased, as Iran has now issued a vague warning to the US not to bring the aircraft carrier John C. Stennis, which exited the Persian Gulf on Tuesday, back into the Gulf.

With all of these events taking place, it would be easy to overlook a strange incident on the Iran-Pakistan border on Sunday. Both Iran and Pakistan now say that Pakistan has detained three Iranian border guards who crossed into Pakistan. The guards shot two men who were in a car they were chasing, and one of the men died. The shooting victims are Pakistani nationals.

One of the most detailed accounts appears in the Washington Post via AP:

Pakistani authorities have yet to decide what to do with three Iranian border guards who they say crossed into southwestern Pakistan while chasing after smugglers and killed one them, a government official said Monday.

The incident occurred Sunday in the Mazah Sar area of Baluchistan province, a desolate, unpopulated region where the border is not clearly marked.

Aalam Farez, a senior government official in Washuk district, where Mazah Sar is located, said the Iranians admitted to inadvertently crossing into Pakistan. But, he said, they claimed the two people they shot — one of whom died — were bystanders and that the people they were chasing escaped.

After the shooting, Pakistani border personnel chased the Iranians back across the border and detained them, Pakistani officials have said. They also seized the surviving gunshot victim and determined both of those who had been shot were petty smugglers.

The Express Tribune (via AFP) adds significant background on the region where this event took place:

The Iranians reached Mazan Sar Mashkail, in Washuk district, three kilometres (1.8miles) inside Pakistan where they opened fire on a vehicle they were chasing, according to officials in Balochistan.

“All three personnel of Iranian border security force were taken into custody for their penetration inside Pakistan and killing a Pakistani national on our soil”, Saeed Ahmad Jamali, Deputy Commissioner of Washuk district told AFP.

/snip/

Mazan Sar Mashkail is around 600 kilometres southwest of Quetta, the main town of insurgency hit Baluchistan province, which borders Iran’s Sistan-Baluchestan province.

Iranian embassy officials in Islamabad were unavailable for comment late Sunday but Iran in the past has blamed a Sunni extremist group, called Jundallah, for launching attacks inside Pakistan [sic] from Sistan-Balochistan.

Jundallah says it is fighting Tehran’s Shiite rule to secure rights for Sunni Balochis who form a significant population in Sistan-Balochistan, which borders both Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Significantly, this AFP article makes no mention of smuggling, so the smuggling characterization appears only in the AP article, which Mehr News cites in its confirmation of the event. And despite the AP article not mentioning Jundallah, it is possible that both stories are correct, since in addition to its terrorism role, Jundallah also has been accused of drug smuggling. (It seems likely that the AFP article meant to say that Iran has blamed Jundallah for attacks inside Iran rather than Pakistan. Jundallah has claimed responsibility for several attacks, see below.)

The potential involvement of Jundallah is highly significant, as evidence has been presented that the Bush administration provided training and financial support. From ABC in 2007:

A Pakistani tribal militant group responsible for a series of deadly guerrilla raids inside Iran has been secretly encouraged and advised by American officials since 2005, U.S. and Pakistani intelligence sources tell ABC News. The group, called Jundullah, is made up of members of the Baluchi tribe and operates out of the Baluchistan province in Pakistan, just across the border from Iran.  It has taken responsibility for the deaths and kidnappings of more than a dozen Iranian soldiers and officials.

The article went on to describe the group’s leader (who was subsequently caught and executed by Iran) as “part drug smuggler.

Seymour Hersh added more in 2008:

The Administration may have been willing to rely on dissident organizations in Iran even when there was reason to believe that the groups had operated against American interests in the past. The use of Baluchi elements, for example, is problematic, Robert Baer, a former C.I.A. clandestine officer who worked for nearly two decades in South Asia and the Middle East, told me. “The Baluchis are Sunni fundamentalists who hate the regime in Tehran, but you can also describe them as Al Qaeda,” Baer told me. “These are guys who cut off the heads of nonbelievers—in this case, it’s Shiite Iranians. The irony is that we’re once again working with Sunni fundamentalists, just as we did in Afghanistan in the nineteen-eighties.” Ramzi Yousef, who was convicted for his role in the 1993 bombing of the World Trade Center, and Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, who is considered one of the leading planners of the September 11th attacks, are Baluchi Sunni fundamentalists.

One of the most active and violent anti-regime groups in Iran today is the Jundallah, also known as the Iranian People’s Resistance Movement, which describes itself as a resistance force fighting for the rights of Sunnis in Iran. “This is a vicious Salafi organization whose followers attended the same madrassas as the Taliban and Pakistani extremists,” Nasr told me. “They are suspected of having links to Al Qaeda and they are also thought to be tied to the drug culture.” The Jundallah took responsibility for the bombing of a busload of Revolutionary Guard soldiers in February, 2007. At least eleven Guard members were killed. According to Baer and to press reports, the Jundallah is among the groups in Iran that are benefitting from U.S. support.

Recall that the AP article describes the Iranian border guards as claiming that the men they shot were not the actual suspects they had been chasing but were bystanders and that it is the Pakistani border officials who claim the men shot were smugglers and presumably were the ones being chased. This situation is remarkably similar to the Raymond Davis incident, where Davis gunned down two Pakistani nationals and then claimed that they were trying to rob him while they were on motorcycles and he was in a car, even though the incident looked more like a “hit” on Davis which he managed to reverse. At the very least, by mentioning Jundallah as even potentially involved, AFP has raised the possibility that a group rumored to be backed by the US (even under Obama) would have been active in cross-border activity at a time of very high tension. The relatively short border region between Iran and Pakistan will bear further watching in the near future.

Many years ago, Jim got a BA in Radiation Biophysics from the University of Kansas. He then got a PhD in Molecular Biology from UCLA and did postdoctoral research in yeast genetics at UC Berkeley and mouse retroviruses at Stanford. He joined biosys in Palo Alto, producing insect parasitic nematodes for pest control. In the early 1990’s, he moved to Gainesville, FL and founded a company that eventually became Entomos. He left the firm as it reorganized into Pasteuria Biosciences and chose not to found a new firm due a clash of values with venture capital investors, who generally lack all values. Upon leaving, he chose to be a stay at home dad, gentleman farmer, cook and horse wrangler. He discovered the online world through commenting at Glenn Greenwald’s blog in the Salon days and was involved in the briefly successful Chris Dodd move to block the bill to renew FISA. He then went on to blog at Firedoglake and served a brief stint as evening editor there. When the Emptywheel blog moved out of Firedoglake back to standalone status, Jim tagged along and blogged on anthrax, viruses, John Galt, Pakistan and Afghanistan. He is now a mostly lapsed blogger looking for a work-around to the depressing realization that pointing out the details of government malfeasance and elite immunity has approximately zero effect.
10 replies
  1. MadDog says:

    Ratchet, ratchet, ratchet:

    “…Iran’s sabre-rattling over the strait and the Gulf has come in response to US preparations to impose tough new sanctions that would ban dealings with Iran’s Central Bank. That would deeply hurt Iran’s oil exports since most countries and companies use the bank to conduct purchases of Iranian crude…

    [snip]

    …French Foreign Minister Alain Juppe said Tuesday that is country wants Europe to agree on similar sanctions against Iran by January 30 to show its determination to stop Iran from developing a nuclear weapon. He told the French television station i>TELE that there is “no doubt” that Iran is continuing with plans to build a bomb…”

  2. Bob Schacht says:

    Thanks for this report, EW.
    However, your last sentence can only be considered true in comparison with longer borders elsewhere. I haven’t checked, but IIRC, the border between Iran and Pakistan is about a thousand miles long, and is about as isolated a place as there is, anywhere in the Middle East.

    Bob in AZ

  3. rugger9 says:

    However, this cannot help Iran, and if there’s a dustup with Pakistan, who will the PRC back? They have ties to both, and FWIW we have animosities with both.

  4. alinaustex says:

    So according to the very credible Mr Baer we were are once again supporting fundamentalist Salafist to further our ‘national interest ” in ‘containing another enemy state’ – in this instance Iran . What could possibly go wrong ?
    And wasn’t it in the early 2000’s that the Iranians nearly went to war with the Afghanistan Taliban ? And long about the same timeline the Iranians where making an overture to the United States regarding a comprehensive re-engagement with the West ? Seems like it was done through the Swiss ambassador or some such .
    The whole interplay with the Iranians is on a slippery slope to a shooting war- and we are playing footsies with the Salafist fundmentalists- as they stage hit and runs from Pakistan against the Iranians. And rugger9@ 5 asked a good question who will the PRC back if Balochistan dustup turns into a major confrontation . There have credible reports over the years that Jundallah also supports fundamental Islamic separatist in Western PRC – (think Kashgir car bombings ) .
    I repeat what could possibly go wrong ?

  5. Jim White says:

    Iran is filling in a few more details on their version of the story. From Mehr News:

    Brigadier General Hossein Zolfaqari, the commander of the border police, has called on the Pakistani border police to release the three Iranian border guards as soon as possible.

    /snip/

    On the details of the incident, he said, “Three nights ago, border guards in the city of Saravan, in the southeastern Iranian province of Sistan and Baluchestan, exchanged fire with a group of criminals and armed smugglers.”

    He added that during the firefight, the Iranian border guards killed two of them and arrested two others while the rest managed to escape into Pakistani soil.

    The commander said that three Iranian border guards chased the smugglers during the night at the zero point of the border and unintentionally crossed into the Pakistani soil before being arrested by their Pakistani counterparts.

    500 kilograms of drugs were also seized as a result of the conflict with the smugglers, he said.

  6. Bob Schacht says:

    @Jim White:

    On the details of the incident, he said, “Three nights ago, border guards in the city of Saravan, in the southeastern Iranian province of Sistan and Baluchestan, exchanged fire with a group of criminals and armed smugglers.”

    These place-names interest me because the first is named for a province in Afghanistan, and the second is named for a province covering a large part of Western Pakistan. It appears to be the largest of Iran’s provinces. The capitol of the province is Zahedan, with a population of about 600,000. Its population has increased six-fold since 1976. There is a railroad line to Quetta in Pakistan, and roads to the capitols of adjacent provinces. Zahedan used to be called “Dozdab”, as it was the meeting place of bandits. In other words, until recently (?), the province has been lawless. Like many places in the middle east, it was not safe to travel alone, and tribes near the major travel routes often extract protection money, etc. from the people in a caravan. Perhaps security has improved recently.

    Bob in AZ

Comments are closed.