Use the Cantor Shellacking to Reverse Course on USA Freedumber

Eric Cantor, who famously held up earthquake relief to his own district on Paygo rules, got his ass handed to him last night by Tea Party candidate Dave Brat.

And while my impression is Cantor lost because of that kind of disdain for his constituents, it is in fact the case that 1) Cantor was a key player in watering down and then passing the USA Freedumber Act and 2) Brat campaigned on an anti-surveillance platform. Which means pundits are already reading Cantor’s defeat as a loss for the NSA.

But it’s only a loss if it leads to the defeat of USA Freedumber, one of the last bills Cantor shepherded through the House before his shellacking.

So I think the privacy community should use it as an opportunity to do what it should have done as soon as USA Freedumb got watered down into USA Freedumber: loudly declare that Jim Sensenbrenner reneged on the deal made in the USA Freedumb Act and that the legislative effort needs to be reset.

I say that because right now the privacy community has lost all its leverage in this process by not loudly coming out against USA Freedumber after Cantor watered it down, by not rallying the privacy community on solid principles. Sure, doing so doesn’t help in the House, where significant damage has already been done. But doing so may be one of the few things that would restore the credibility of the institutional players and restore some kind of unity to the effort.

Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Reddit0Share on Facebook0Google+0Email to someone

11 Responses to Use the Cantor Shellacking to Reverse Course on USA Freedumber

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
Emptywheel Twitterverse
bmaz @MikeFreddoso @Popehat @deviantollam My rule of thumb is: You can ask for too little in a notice of claim, but you can't ask for too much.
bmaz @MikeFreddoso @Popehat @deviantollam Oh, there is a legitimate claim, and a significant one. How much exactly does that mean? Who knows?
bmaz Thanksgiving Moonrise In The Cactus Patch
emptywheel @blogdiva Look for the pic of her greeting the pope. She's taller than he is.
emptywheel @antagonismorg Here's my bacon on turkey instructions as if it weren't self-evident. @astepanovich
emptywheel @antagonismorg It's an old family trick, some grandmother of mine gets credit, I think @astepanovich
emptywheel @grisuy More NYT Food writing fail. I'm thinking of making this a downright obsession.
bmaz Fair is fair. @CNN earlier put up Gilliam who clearly has no clue on real use of force law. But @JeffreyToobin + @SunnyHostin were excellent
emptywheel RT @jbarro: All the stages of the GOP establishment's grief over Donald Trump will be funny except Acceptance.
emptywheel Also, Donald recommends NYT do away with standard punctuation--especially use of apostrophes, bc those are annoying.
June 2014
« May   Jul »