Obama Still Clinging to 352,000 Afghan National Security Force Size Myth

Before the outbreak of green on blue killings that eventually led to a significant interruption in the training of Afghan security forces last September, it was impossible to read a statement from the US military or NATO regarding future plans without encountering a reference to a required 352,000 force size for combined Afghan National Security Forces. It was our training of the ANSF that was touted as our primary reason for remaining in Afghanistan because we need those trained troops available to take over security responsibility as we withdraw. I have been insisting since the interruption that it will be impossible to continue to claim that a functional ANSF force size of 352,000 can be achieved, as the known high rate of attrition continued during the training interruption. No new troop size prediction has emerged, but it was significant to me that references to the 352,000 force size claim had seemed to disappear.

Last night, President Barack Obama announced in his State of the Union address that he intends to withdraw about half the troops now in Afghanistan within the next twelve months, but he made no direct reference ANSF force size. Here are the three short paragraphs on Afghanistan in the speech as found in the transcript of his address:

Tonight, we stand united in saluting the troops and civilians who sacrifice every day to protect us.  Because of them, we can say with confidence that America will complete its mission in Afghanistan and achieve our objective of defeating the core of al Qaeda.  (Applause.)

Already, we have brought home 33,000 of our brave servicemen and women.  This spring, our forces will move into a support role, while Afghan security forces take the lead.  Tonight, I can announce that over the next year, another 34,000 American troops will come home from Afghanistan.  This drawdown will continue and by the end of next year, our war in Afghanistan will be over.  (Applause.)

Beyond 2014, America’s commitment to a unified and sovereign Afghanistan will endure, but the nature of our commitment will change. We’re negotiating an agreement with the Afghan government that focuses on two missions — training and equipping Afghan forces so that the country does not again slip into chaos, and counterterrorism efforts that allow us to pursue the remnants of al Qaeda and their affiliates.

Despite the specific force numbers cited with respect to US forces, Obama merely mentions “Afghan security forces” without telling us how many of them there will be. Resorting to the more detailed Afghanistan Fact Sheet released last night by the White House, however, shows that Obama still clings to the myth that there are 352,000 members of the ANSF. The Fact Sheet even goes to so far as to claim that this force level will be maintained for the next three years. I don’t believe I have seen this three year claim before: Continue reading

Emptywheel Twitterverse
bmaz @Travis_Waldron I bet it is better than that, by how much I have no idea.
bmaz @Ali_Gharib I hear there is medication for that! But okay, we'll find a place.
emptywheel Jeb! won't take out Trump bc Cruz is a more difficult target. Leadership!
bmaz @LuckyJimJD @AnthonyMKreis @ajccourts Huh. Thanks. Seems like there would be some duty to join, but I guess not!
emptywheel Republican insiders aghast that reality show star is winning their Reality Show primary.
bmaz @Travis_Waldron They will bid and get it again, but bid will look different next time I bet.
bmaz @Travis_Waldron In fairness, the picture for the valley as a whole is much more positive. But bleak for the host city of Glendale.
bmaz @Ali_Gharib Family deal. Wife+daughter never been, love theater shows.
bmaz RT @benwizner: Collected in one place: "The Videos That Are Putting Race and Policing Into Sharp Relief," via @nytimes.
emptywheel @empiricalerror If it were released more skeptical readers might read it @morisy
bmaz Why is attorney @DanielQHerbert all over @CNN yakking about his case. He looks silly and doing a disservice trying case in media. Stooge.
November 2015
« Oct