ConEd

Obama Will Propose New Efforts to Make Our Creaky Physically Dangerous Critical Infrastructure CyberSafe

One of Obama’s key proposals in tonight’s State of the Union will be yet another effort to shore up the cybersecurity of our critical infrastructure.

As a threshold matter, I find it a remarkable coinkydink that the WaPo just reported the leaked findings of an NIE saying that the Chinese (and Israelis and Russians and the French, but the Chinese are bigger and badder, apparently) continue to rob us blind via cybertheft. I look forward to learning whether this — unlike the convenient drone rule book leaks supporting John Brennan’s confirmation — get reported as sanctioned leaks, as required under the Intelligence Authorization.

And speaking of John Brennan, he’s the Homeland Security Czar. A big part of his job is keeping us safe from precisely these kinds of attacks. So why didn’t he get a single question about why he should be CIA Director considering he has been such an abject failure keeping us safe from cyberattacks? (He was asked a question about CIA’s role in cybersecurity, but not asked to explain why he has been such a failure in his current role.)

Now, frankly, I don’t know that that is much John Brennan’s fault. Folks will say that the problem is — as it has been since Richard Clarke first started fearmongering on this front — that corporations won’t participate willingly and no one is going to make them.

But the proposal — which you’ll see if you tune in — doesn’t change that. It’s still voluntary.

And here’s the thing that all the cyberexperts in the world seem to be missing. Not only are the private owners of our critical infrastructure unwilling to fix their cyberdefenses. They’re not willing to keep their brick and mortar infrastructure up to date either. See, for example, PG&E or ConEd‘s recent records, for example.

Look, if these companies refuse to keep up their physical infrastructure and their cyber infrastructure, there’s probably an underlying reason motivating their negligence that no amount of immunity or winks or risk-free information sharing on the cyber side is going to fix. Moreover, if they are physically fundamentally unsafe, no amount of tinkering with their cybersecurity is going to make them safe. They’ll be vulnerable to a terrorist attack and be vulnerable to not entirely random failures and explosions.

You need to solve the underlying problem if you want to keep our critical infrastructure safe. And yet another EO, particularly one limited to cybersecurity and not affect brick and mortar integrity, will not do that.

Updated: Reading Obama’s longer proposal, it does aim to increase the “resiliency” of our physical infrastructure too. So it is not limited to cyber. That said, the underlying problem remains. Private companies aren’t spending the money to invest in this, whether it is physical resilience (or bare minimum functionality) or cyberdefense.

Emptywheel Twitterverse
emptywheel Sony's only on the hook for $20M for gross negligence in protecting employee data? http://t.co/RqezRqmpmD Fed employees take note.
9mreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV Anti-vaxxers=murderers. https://t.co/osiW0Z8f6F
13mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @radicalmandy You tell the Lowes people that only GCHQ gets to laugh at Amnesty employees. (And congrats, btw)
17mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @agidari The report requires judges authorizing wiretaps under 18 USC 2518 and states to report. That's not all judges is it? @wendyck
35mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz Infotainment hosts @WolfBlitzer + @GloriaBorger on @CNN cackling about Trump instead of reporting that hes ignorant racist lout. #BadJournos
40mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @billmon1 Sure, and if he were raising big Wall Street money Wall Street might let him win. But he will not have been purchased like that.
50mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel Is it too late to invite Trump? https://t.co/nKjYSoviHz
52mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @cristianafarias @azatty For the most part, they have all gone to Sue Bolton, who is very good and efficient at dispensing with them
55mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel RT @NSArchive: CIA's "scary" bin Laden doll sold at auction in LA; CIA continues to ignore our #FOIA for dox on it #FRINFORMSUM https://t.c…
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @agidari No, my Q was, for example, whether Fed one counts NYPD wiretaps. It only reports state, not muni, wiretaps, right? @wendyck
1hreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV Outdoor chores delayed by nearby weather, but no actual rain here. We should at least get rain on pastures if I can't work...
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @RachelBLevinson Nevertheless, given that they're not protecting USP dragnet data w/tech audits, fairly safe to assume they're not 12333.
1hreplyretweetfavorite
July 2015
S M T W T F S
« Jun    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031