Drone Rule Book

John Brennan Can’t Even Last One 3-Hour Hearing without Engaging in Information Asymmetry

One of the questions Dianne Feinstein asked John Brennan in his confirmation hearing last week pertained to the role in approving drone strikes he’ll have at CIA. He refused the answer the question directly because the program is classified.

Feinstein: I’d like to ask you about the status of the Administration’s efforts to institutionalize rules and procedures for the conduct of drone strikes. In particular, how do you see your role as CIA Director in that approval process?

Brennan: Chairman, as this committee knows and I’m sure wants to continue to protect certain covert action activities. But let me talk generally about the counterterrorism program and the role of CIA and this effort to try to institutionalize and to ensure we have as rigorous a process as possible that we feel that we’re taking the appropriate actions at the appropriate time. The President has insisted that any actions we take will be legally grounded, will be  thoroughly anchored in intelligence, will have the appropriate review process, approval process before any action is contemplated, included those actions that might involve the use of lethal force.The different parts of the government that are involved in this process are involved in the interagency, and my role as the President’s counterterrorism advisor was to help to orchestrate this effort over the past four years to ensure again that any actions we take fully comport with our law and meet the standards that I think this committee and the American people fully expect of us as far as taking actions we need to protect the American people but at the same time ensuring we do everything possible to ensure we need to resort to lethal force.

Brennan was equally evasive to similar questions in the hearing, and did not really answer a very simple question in his questions for the committee, whether the drone rule book had been finalized (see question 39: Is there a drone rulebook? A: Not so much a rulebook as little scraps of paper strewn around I sometimes lose).

But let it be noted that when the Chairwoman of the committee purportedly overseeing this program asked him what his role would be, as CIA Director, under the new rule book — a topic which has been addressed in part in the press — he suggested he couldn’t answer because it was classified.

Less than three hours later, this exchange occurred.

Burr: On January 15th of this year, the President signed the 2012 Intelligence Authorization Act, which requires congressional notification of any authorized disclosure of national intelligence. Now, we’ve not received any notification of authorized disclosures. Have there been any authorized disclosures to your knowledge?

Brennan: I would like to say that since you haven’t received any notification there haven’t been.

Burr: Would you consider the information reported in the press about the counterterrorism playbook unauthorized disclosure?

Brennan: Um, I don’t know which piece you’re talking about. There’s been a lot of discussion out there in the media and in the newspapers about this, so I don’t know specifically about any classified information — the fact that the Administration may be going through a process to try to institutionalize, codify, make as rigorous as possible our processes and procedures in and of itself is not a classified issue. So those details that are classified — I don’t know of any that came out in some of those reports.

Burr: If there are classified information that’s out there, and it’s not authorized, was there a crime report filed relative to the playbook?

Brennan: Um, presumably there was, Senator. Those decisions as far as initiating criminal investigations are done by those departments and agencies that have stewardship of that classified information. And in discussions with the Department of Justice they make the determination whether or not, in light of the fact that so many people have access to it, how they can proceed with some type of criminal investigation.

There have been two major stories on the drone rule book since Obama signed the new intelligence authorization and each contains information that is almost certainly classified. This January 19 WaPo story reveals that CIA Director John Brennan won’t have to play by the rules for the next year in Pakistan.

None of those rules applies to the CIA drone campaign in Pakistan, which began under President George W. Bush. The agency is expected to give the U.S. ambassador to Pakistan advance notice on strikes. But in practice, officials said, the agency exercises near complete control over the names on its target list and decisions on strikes.

Continue reading

Emptywheel Twitterverse
bmaz @Millicentsomer Lili, have another glass of wine, there is no bottom to the hole you just jumped in.
5hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PhoenixWomanMN @armandodkos In fact, I was much more favorable to HRC in primary until I saw how dishonest and petty her team is.
5hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PhoenixWomanMN @armandodkos I do NOT hate Clinton, I admire her in very many ways. Think some of her policies are atrocious+prefer Sanders.
6hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PhoenixWomanMN @armandodkos Perhaps I mistook you for someone else. But you can flat out stick your trite little CDS shit.
6hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PhoenixWomanMN @armandodkos This is the same asinine horseshit you pulled in 2008. well you can fuck right off with that.
6hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @richganske That RAF bar is pretty awesome looking
6hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @shannynmoore No kidding. Just saw someone compare them to INXS. Not seeing that in the least.
6hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @ZoeNoeTek Yep, you too.
6hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PhoenixWomanMN @armandodkos Team Clinton can stick that shit. Why don't you account for the hundreds of thousands dead from her sick wars?
6hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @ZoeNoeTek No. Frankly anybody that would want the job of President is probably the wrong person to have it.
7hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PhoenixWomanMN @armandodkos Like I give a flying fuck about Devine? Seriously spare me this two bit Clintonian horseshoe.
7hreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @ZoeNoeTek Heh, you mean like having Bill Gates clean up the internet?
7hreplyretweetfavorite
February 2016
S M T W T F S
« Jan    
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
2829