James Cartright

The Guy Who’s Always Right, Harold Koh, Changes His Mind

In her profile of Harold Koh’s flip-flop on drones (and counterterrorism generally), Tara McKelvey shows that Koh joined the Administration with such certitude about his initial position–that drones were assassinations–he pissed everyone off.

“Everybody hated him,” says Cartwright, describing how Koh would rip into him and other people: “He would say, ‘Oh, you military guys, you’re just so stupid.’ ”

One of Koh’s key objections–and one of the obvious weak points in the Administration’s current justification on drones–had to do with the difficulty in showing that drone targets presented an imminent threat.

Koh referred to President Bush as the nation’s “torturer in chief” and told a New York Times reporter in December 2002 that the policy of targeted killings seemed to violate the government’s longstanding ban on assassination: “The question is, what factual showing will demonstrate that they had warlike intentions against us and who sees that evidence before any action is taken?”

But now, after seeing a bunch of classified information that should not change the broad outlines of the law, Koh has decided they’re not extrajudicial killings and assassinations after all. He denies this is a change in his opinion.

“I have never changed my mind,” he says. “Not from before I was in the government—or after.”

Sure, Koh is just one lawyer reviewing these questions, bureaucratically (though not morally, given Koh’s past comments on counterterrorism) a relatively minor one. But McKelvey’s portrait of Koh shows that what has remained unchanged about Koh are not his legal stances, but his certitude that he is correct, whatever his current legal stance.

Compare that with the thoughts of the guy who used to have Koh’s job, William Taft IV.

I ask Taft, “Why does the law matter when everyone thinks something is OK?”

“That is actually a deep question. When a human life is at stake, there needs to be a process for determining that a person can be executed or shot in an armed conflict,” he says. “Otherwise, we will have an individual just deciding that he wants to kill someone.”

“What if it’s the president?” I ask.

“Especially,” said Taft. “He’s the main person who might possibly have this authority, and you’ve got to watch it.”

We have a system that ensures that someone challenges the opinions of those, like Koh, who may be certain but may also be suffering from the tunnel vision of someone seeing the world of classified information our “democratic” government won’t share.  It’s a process that guarantees all the very smart and unwavering in a belief in their own correctness have someone who challenges their certitude.

It’s called due process.

There’s a reason why the people who are certain they’re already right or the people who have unlimited power should not have the ability to approve the killing of someone else with no review. It’s because those people will be least apt to question their own beliefs.

Emptywheel Twitterverse
emptywheel Anyone want to give me $1 for every news article I find that conflates phone dragnet w/Section 215 between now and June?
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel Man. I was already gonna watch Bibi for the State of the Union like procession at the beginning (I hope), but intel leaking?!?! Popcorn.
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel RT @mawilner: White House officials warn: Declassifying US intel on #Iran in Congress speech would constitute an act of betrayal by @Netany
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @nickmanes1 It's like falling off an ice-covered sidewalk. It comes back almost immediately.
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @nickmanes1 Oh Manes, has it been so long since we got to freezing you forget that's when worst ice storms hit?
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @digby56 And 5 of them are children of wealth (maybe 4.5, cause Gates had his own career).
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @nickmanes1 Good! Cause there's a whole new dose of ice coming tomorrow!
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @mattblaze I saw we build a Wisdom Community to combat the Intelligence Community.
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel RT @mgsledge: Chicago media is reprinting police press releases about Homan Square ... and not in a metaphorical sense http://t.co/diBhEaSh
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @kurtopsahl I've got a good idea! Let's give them immunity!
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @electrospaces The hand off between NSA and FBI is very much a black box (tho more keeps moving to FBI bc easier sharing rules) @dametzger
2hreplyretweetfavorite
March 2015
S M T W T F S
« Feb    
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031