Have 1,485 Innocent Americans Been Investigated for Researching Pressure Cookers?

Update: One of Catalano’s family members’ former employers tipped off the local cops to searches for backpack and pressure cooker on their computer. 

I have been warning about the criminalization of common items since it became clear in 2009 the FBI had investigated 3 purported (and apparently innocent) Najibullah Zazi “associates” for buying beauty supplies.

So I am thoroughly unsurprised that Michele Catalano’s family got questioned by 6 members of the Joint Terrorism Task Force because she researched pressure cookers online and her husband researched backpacks and her son clicked stories describing the Boston Marathon bomb.

I had researched pressure cookers. My husband was looking for a backpack. And maybe in another time those two things together would have seemed innocuous, but we are in “these times” now. And in these times, when things like the Boston bombing happen, you spend a lot of time on the internet reading about it and, if you are my exceedingly curious news junkie of a twenty-ear-old son, you click a lot of links when you read the myriad of stories. You might just read a CNN piece about how bomb making instructions are readily available on the internet and you will in all probability, if you are that kid, click the link provided.

Which might not raise any red flags. Because who wasn’t reading those stories? Who wasn’t clicking those links? But my son’s reading habits combined with my search for a pressure cooker and my husband’s search for a backpack set off an alarm of sorts at the joint terrorism task force headquarters.

It seems to have worked out okay for this apparently comfortable and apparently white family (though I am curious whether the FBI had investigated her husband’s business trips to Korea and China before they showed up).

But this was just one JTTF squad. And that JTTF told her husband that they conduct 100 such investigations a week.

They mentioned that they do this about 100 times a week. And that 99 of those visits turn out to be nothing. I don’t know what happens on the other 1% of visits and I’m not sure I want to know what my neighbors are up to.

It has been 15 weeks since the Boston Marathon attack. While I’m sure all these searches, by this one JTTF, weren’t in search of pressure cookers, just imagine that 100 pressure cooker investigations a week have been conducted by all JTTFs together? That would mean 1,485 innocent Americans — plus the 15 the FBI considers not so innocent or perhaps worthy of entrapment — have been targeted because of completely innocent First Amendment online searches.

But don’t worry. Keith Alexander and James Clapper assure you they’re not watching Americans’ communications.

10 replies
  1. Arbusto says:

    So if I search on line for a gasket for my leaky (you know what) my chances of a visit from my local Gestapo franchise goes up exponentially. I guess this inquisition will at least support the local economy, but remember to use cash and a disguise when shopping and don’t read blogs like emptywheel for fear of a midnight visit.

  2. der says:

    Those numbers seem a little low which is a good reason to put Ray Kelly on the job ASAP, he’ll post g-men at Wal Mart exits. And Tommy F will be like “kick the doors down, suck on this…..” Also, too put some of those unemployed layabouts to work at $9.95/hr.

  3. mpatteror says:

    What are we going to do about this? Seriously, what on earth can we possibly do? I joined the EFF, the ACLU, and called my rep. My senators are Wyden and Merkley. I don’t think protests matter a hill of beans in this country anymore. I voted for Obama twice, partially based on his stance on civil liberties. What a joke on us that turned out to be. Our government has been rendered useless because of the filibuster and gerrymandering. The supreme court is owned by corporations, both parties by the lobbyists. A very disillusioned American here…

  4. earlofhuntingdon says:

    What a superb example of wasteful security theater. It’s a wonderful example, too, of the intentional intimidation of the citizenry, no matter how laughably inept it seems in anticipating or investigating crimes. If investigating the haystack, looking for the needle were the real goal, why on earth devote six agents at a time?

    It’s been said that generals (and politicians) fight the last war over and over again until they win it, changes in warfare and in the world notwithstanding. It’s a syndrome wonderfully adapted to bureaucratic inertia, budgetary politics, and ass covering.

    If these raids were designed to misdirect resources away from criminal plots, they could not be more effective.

  5. Ed says:

    So was it “pressure cooker” search by mom, or “pressure cooker bomb” by her or someone else? The tech article claims the latter reported by the cops?

  6. DA says:


    Yes, I just read about TATP and used startpage.com to search on it, but frankly … I’m not sure I want to click on those links. A youtube vid on how to make it? Do I want to leave that track with google?

    Time for me to finally set up that VPN. And the encrypted DNS. Now if I could just get my friends to encrypt their emails …

  7. Bill Michtom says:

    @mpatteror: That you voted for Obama AFTER he voted for the FISA Amendments Act (in 2008!) indicates that we all need to be more aware of the fascists pretending to be liberals.

Comments are closed.