Discerning Russian Trolls Appreciate Truth Social’s Treatment of Fake Accounts

Today, the former President tweeted that his failing social media company, “IS GREAT. THE REAL VOICE OF AMERICA.”

A number of people suggested he was doing so in an effort to preserve value before he can start dumping the stock.

If it was, though, it seemed to come just as an early morning spike in the stock price started to collapse, even as other Truth Social executives have started unloading their stock before Trump can do so later this month.

But I was interested in the post for another reason.

The most interesting details from the Doppelganger dossier released with a takedown request last week pertain to how the Russian trolls described efforts by social media companies to police inauthentic content.

A media plan proposed targeting Ukrainian audiences on Facebook and Xitter — the administrators of which, the plan claimed, “have a pro-Ukrainian position” that leads them to “subject communities promotion pro-Russian narratives to strict moderation rules” — by spending at least four months building a following before expressing pro-Russian views.

They’re effectively building sleeper cells of trolling accounts to evade moderation of inauthentic content.

But other Russian trolls were undaunted.

The Good Old USA project would target Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, Xitter, and Reddit precisely because those channels were, “free from ‘democratic censorship'” (in scare quotes).

As Yael Roth testified to Congress last year, the efforts to build an election integrity function at social media companies in response to Russia’s 2016 influence operation were “fundamentally bipartisan.” But now, Russian trolls aiming to tamper in the 2024 refer to such moderation efforts as “democratic censorship.”

But even Mark Zuckerberg’s company was viewed with some suspicion. A different document described that Xitter was the only mass US social media platform which Russia could use, because Meta “actively collaborates with the National Security Agency.”

Xitter, the document predicted, would start policing content more closely as the November election approached.

By far the most interesting observation about which social media platforms were appropriate for Russian propaganda campaigns, however, is this one, which appears in a Guerrilla Media campaign to exacerbate polarization in the US, in part by complaining about the cost of supporting Ukraine. As other plans did, this one described ways to bypass the moderation on Facebook, Xitter, and YouTube, in this case, by making perishable accounts. It also described the limits on YouTube, which tends to scrutinize accounts once they accrue 100,000 subscribers (which may explain why Russia was so interested in paying Dave Rubin and Tim Pool, because they organically have ten times that).

But then there’s a redacted comment about “Candidate A,” the substitution used to refer to Trump throughout this dossier.

Except it’s not a comment about Trump. By context, it’s obviously a comment about his social media site.

Helpfully, the reference to Truth Social is not redacted in the affidavit itself.

SDA documents include a proposal for another campaign focused on influencing the United States, titled “The Guerrilla Media Campaign in the United States.” See Exhibit 9. 18 The Guerilla Media Campaign focused on exploiting the perceived polarization of U.S. society by focusing on eight “Campaign Topics.” As reflected in the proposal, SDA anticipated using social media profiles on Facebook, X (formerly known as Twitter), YouTube, and Truth Social but noted that with “Facebook, Twitter and YouTube, we need to create multiple ‘perishable’ accounts, primarily for the work with comments.” [my emphasis]

By context, the affidavit explains what distinguishes the social media platform of Candidate A, Truth Social: Unlike Facebook, Xitter, and YouTube, Truth Social doesn’t require perishable accounts to evade censorship.

Whenever Russian trolls wrote this, then, they perceived that Truth Social did not exercise the kind of moderation of obvious Russian propaganda as Truth Social’s bigger rivals.

Mind you, the other references to American social media platforms suggest that these Russian trolls don’t consider Truth Social to have the mass reach that Meta platforms and Xitter have. Maybe Truth Social wouldn’t be a failing social media platform if it were less friendly to Russian trolls pretending to be Americans.

“TRUTH SOCIAL IS GREAT. THE REAL VOICE OF AMERICA!,” Trump tweeted out the week after a report on how Russia exploits US social media platforms to spread propaganda.

Only, certain discerning Russian trolls find Truth Social to be particularly welcoming to Russian voices, even those only pretending to be American voices.

image_print
21 replies
      • Steve in Manhattan says:

        Sinclair is ruthless enough and greedy enough to do Leo’s bidding, but then again there’s probably a slew of right-wing operators willing to sign on to his plan.

  1. Sussex Trafalgar says:

    Excellent posting/piece!

    The disinformation and propaganda business Putin has been practicing since his KGB days is mature and effective.

    I wouldn’t be surprised if an in-depth study proved Musk, Thiel and other right wing billionaires with similar authoritarian ideologies who covet doing business with Putin were, in fact, financed by Putin during the incubation and early stages of their respective business careers.

    And Trump is nothing but a low-hanging piece of malignant narcissist pathological liar fruit that Putin continues to use to his advantage.

    Organized crime doesn’t work in mysterious ways.

    • Matt___B says:

      In keeping with the fruit analogy: how long can “low-hanging” fruit remain on the vine before rotting and falling to the ground?

    • gruntfuttock says:

      ‘And Trump is nothing but a low-hanging piece of malignant narcissist pathological liar fruit that Putin continues to use to his advantage. ‘

      The only thing worse than being a Russian propagandist is not being a Russian propagandist.

      As long as it gets my tired, haggard, orange face in the news.

      ;-)

    • eyesoars says:

      That would make it extra ironic that Musk, after being insulted by Roscosmos, created SpaceX, which essentially put Roscosmos out of business for non-Russian launches, decimating one of Russia’s sources of hard foreign currency.

    • ToldainDarkwater says:

      I dunno, Musk has never had much in the way of, ahem, people skills. I’ve seen this often – spectrum techie guy gets very libertarian if not authoritarian because it’s “logical”. Except for the part that other people don’t like it. But they are just dumb and don’t know what’s good for them.

      Musk seems to have taken a turn for the worse though, when his daughter came out as trans. Of course, rugged he-man Putin will have none of that trans nonsense – I expect this was a very significant entry point for a Russian influence op.

      Also, most of his idiocy with Twitter/X can be explained by “Elon Musk does not understand people”.

      • Ginevra diBenci says:

        I’m ready to call it: Elon’s not that smart.

        Certainly nowhere close to as smart as he thinks he is. His greatest talent seems to have been convincing other people–with money–of this nonexistent genius.

  2. Matt Foley says:

    Donald J. Trump
    @realdonaldtrump
    The Dow Jones Industrial just closed above 29,000! You are so lucky to have me as your President With Joe Hiden’ it would crash
    Sep 2nd 2020 – 4:05:43 PM EST·Twitter for iPhone

    Fun fact: DJIA is at 40790 as I write this.

    He’s a business genius! He’s gonna fix the economy and make all you MAGAs rich again!

  3. vigetnovus says:

    Is it just me, or does that Ukrainian comms plan sound a lot like Good Ole Manafort’s prior messaging plans in the same country? I can just hear his voice reading it, the style is unmistakable.

    I think you said in one of the other threads, Marcy, that you suspect Manafort may have a hand in these shenanigans???

    • emptywheel says:

      I would be unsurprised if he was still sharing strategy. Now, at least one of these docs–one hoping to sow a war with Mexico–was especially garbage. But others did sound very much like Manafort.

    • Zinsky123 says:

      If there is Russian disinformation to be exploited, you can be sure Paul Manafort is there. I sure hope FBI/NSA has ears and eyes on this guy, because he would sell out America in a heartbeat for the right price!

  4. Matt___B says:

    Trump company stock closed at $18.04 today, that’s $.11 higher than your screenshot from this morning, but a $.94 gain from its closing price on Friday. Far cry from its $66.22 peak on 3/27/24. Maybe this is why he thinks the economy is “terrible” right now?

  5. TooLoose LeTruck says:

    Ha! I’ve been watching the price of Donnie’s stock go up and down and down and down for months now…

    I just wish I had started shorting the stock when it was selling for just shy of $80 a share. I could have made some decent money by now. I was… confident… all along in my opinion that the company was going to pancake completely when the time came, and that time appears to be drawing near.

    What good could you possibly find to say about a company run by Devin Nunes?

    What’s even funnier to me is that I suspect Trump will have absolutely no qualms about fleecing his own supporters when he can start dumping his stock. He won’t hesitate in the least to clean them out completely. Not a good look!

    I do feel a little sorry, and just a little, for anyone who bought the stock at $80 a share.

    I’ve thought for quite some time that the collapse of Trump’s media company right before the election might prove to be the final nail in his political coffin…

  6. freebird says:

    If this stock was under someone else’s name it would be worthless and subject to an SEC investigation. If Trump tried to sell his 114 million shares immediately the stock would be on a moribund spiral. A 100k sell order without a corresponding buy order crashes many stocks on any given day. I suspect that some well heeled Trumpies are bolstering the stock’s value. In the end, the retail investors otherwise known as Trump supporters will be left holding a bag of dreck.

    • TooLoose LeTruck says:

      Yup!

      When you’re right, you’re right…

      And I agree completely with everything you said…

      Dreck is too polite of a word to describe what they’ll be left holding.

Comments are closed.