Stephen Miller Makes a Case to Defund or Deport Elon Musk
Over the weekend, ICE arrested one of the people involved in Columbia’s pro-Palestinian protests, Mahmoud Khalil. It appears that they first stopped him with the intent of arresting him on a claim his student visa had been canceled; but even after they confirmed he was a Green Card holder, they detained him anyway.
On Saturday, Department of Homeland Security (DHS) officers detained Mahmoud Khalil – a recent Columbia University graduate who helped lead the Gaza solidarity encampment – at his New York City home, an apartment building owned by the school, says advocates.
According to the advocates, at around 8:30 PM, Khalil and his wife – who is eight months pregnant – had just unlocked the door to their building when two plainclothes DHS agents pushed inside behind them. The agents allegedly did not identify themselves at first, instead asking for Khalil’s identity before detaining him.
The agents proceeded to tell Khalil’s wife that if she did not leave her husband and go to their apartment, they would arrest her too. The agents claimed that the State Department had revoked Khalil’s student visa, with one agent presenting what he claimed was a warrant on his cell phone. But Khalil, according to advocates, has a green card. Khalil’s wife went to their apartment to get the green card.
“He has a green card,” an agent apparently said on the phone, confused by the matter. But then after a moment, the agent claimed that the State Department had “revoked that too.”
Meanwhile, Khalil had been on the phone with his attorney, Amy Greer who was trying to intervene, asking why he was being detained, if they had a warrant, and explaining that Khalil was a green card holder. The attorney had circled back to demanding to see a warrant when the agents apparently instead hung up the phone.
Khalil was initially detained in Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody in downtown New York, pending an appearance before an immigration judge. Greer said they now do not know his precise whereabouts. They were initially told he was sent to an ICE facility in Elizabeth, New Jersey. But when his wife tried to visit him, she was told he wasn’t there. They have received reports that he may be transferred as far away as Louisiana.
This feels like another bone-headed move — like the firing of FEMA workers who were dutifully helping try to claw back funds already granted to NYC and the attempted investigation of an EPA worker who didn’t do what a Project Veritas video suggested — which the Administration will engage in further corruption to try to defend, making it and the authoritarianism far worse.
People will be fired.
Explanations will be ret-coned.
And either they’ll have to let Khalil free or — more likely — the Trump Administration will attempt to find cause, possibly criminal charges, to attempt to hold him longer (he has, indeed, been located in Jena, Louisiana). Trump will rely heavily on War on Terror precedents that allow the Executive to scream “terror” and with that detain even Green Card holders.
As we wait for better answers about what happened to Khalil, right wingers have taken to Xitter to wave their dicks around.
Newly elected right wing Congressman Brandon Gill, for example, suggested that “maybe we shouldn’t tolerate foreigners seizing control of US academic buildings (while including a screen cap that said Khalil was not in the group that occupied the building).
Gill is calling for the government to take action against foreigners seizing academic buildings even as South African immigrant Elon Musk takes over Department of Education, doing far more damage than protestors did.
And Stephen Miller insisted that the US would send any foreigners sympathizing with terrorism home.
Of course, one of Miller’s chief allies, Elon Musk, routinely platforms people sympathizing with far right terrorism — indeed, he played a direct role in ginning up riots in the UK and elsewhere.
The basis of this crackdown are two executive orders, admittedly focused on schools rather than government contractors, using Title VI funding as a means to dictate what otherwise First Amendment protected entities enjoy. (Note that Khalil’s arrest is inconsistent with Trump’s decision to strip $400 million in funds from Columbia, which would suggest the university, not Khalil did something wrong.)
But it nevertheless remains true that, to the extent that Xitter is protected speech (it is! just like university campuses!), Trump’s EO envisions intervening when government contractors don’t do enough to combat antisemitism.
And compared to Columbia, Elon Musk has been downright solicitous of antisemitism.
Musk also played a direct role in the recent German elections, speaking to the party conference of the neo-Nazi (Nazi-adjacent? Nazi-curious?) AfD, which had the best national electoral results in its history.
There’s definitely a “see no evil” thing going on in the right wing press about this… For example, The Free Press has a very muted response to Musk and mostly favorable coverage of all this. The end result is that even my Israeli family is unaware of Musk’s playing footsie with neo-Nazis….. scary!
I’ve chatted with enough Germans involved enough in politics to know that it’s definitely more adjacent than curious, and probably more than that. The AfD is frequently under investigation, formal and informal, for just how far its right-wing links are. To have such a high-ranking US official (de forma, since clearly not de jure) not only meet with them but cheer them on will obliterate, near irrevocably, a certain level of trust between the two countries.
Not only Musk, but also J.D. Vance, met personally with with Alice Weidel, the current leader of AfD, while the Munich security conference was taking place.
Weidel is practically a carbon copy of the new Le Pen: a softer, gentler facade on a party that deep-down arguably hasn’t changed an inch (or centimeter, to be regionally appropriate). Bonus points that she identifies as a member of the LBTGQ+ coalition, guess she’s forgotten what AfD perspectives have been on that….and what their source inspiration felt on the matter. That meeting was a true betrayal of our longstanding agreements with several rather right-leaning German parties.
Not just Musk. Vance did it too. Which makes it at least semi-official.
The language in DHS’s Xeet is really shocking:
“Khalil led activities aligned to [sic] Hamas …”
A new form of `parallel construction’. No need for material support.
How long before this is applied to citizens?
https://bsky.app/profile/petersterne.com/post/3ljyizp2xu22d
I’ve mentioned this before, but Elno is himself probalby an illegal immigrant by violating the terms of his H-7B visa at Stanford. In short, he blew off class and worked. Lying on naturalization docs (which I am pretty sure included questions about prior visas) means the naturalization can be rescinded and there is plenty of precedent for that.
However, in all things political: IOKIYAR.
In his case, also a billionaire (thanks to the work of others) and has bought the ear of The Felon Guy and most of the Rs (and, I suspect, some of the Ds) in Congress.
First, they came for the Palestinians, and I did nothing, for I was not Palestinian.
Posted today on his TS account, and who is going to stop him? And how?
“Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
Following my previously signed Executive Orders, ICE proudly apprehended and detained Mahmoud Khalil, a Radical Foreign Pro-Hamas Student on the campus of Columbia University. This is the first arrest of many to come. We know there are more students at Columbia and other Universities across the Country who have engaged in pro-terrorist, anti-Semitic, anti-American activity, and the Trump Administration will not tolerate it. Many are not students, they are paid agitators. We will find, apprehend, and deport these terrorist sympathizers from our country — never to return again. If you support terrorism, including the slaughtering of innocent men, women, and children, your presence is contrary to our national and foreign policy interests, and you are not welcome here. We expect every one of America’s Colleges and Universities to comply. Thank you!”
Khalil has a green card.
The Felon Guy is doing the work of Netanyahu and Putin, neither of whom are our friends.
“If you support terrorism…”
Clearly he is making no distinction between citizens and visitors, despite his eager use of “Radical Foreign” rhetoric as a flourish.
Timothy Snyder teaches that dictators render language meaningless. His article on the exploitation of “antisemitism” explicates the administration’s hypocrisy. I would add to the list “terrorist.”
Arresting people on false premises and then blasting it out are terrorist acts. Trump’s entire post is intended to terrorize students and anyone else into submission to whatever he says. “If you support terrorism”? What he means: if you have the courage to stand up to the most powerful terrorists in the world, they will train their sights on YOU.
I agree with you.
A couple of things:
‘Terrorism’ is a label used to scare opponents into silence, and what happened to Khalil even when he invoked his right to an attorney by agents waving around likely-to-be-phony IDs and warrants on an app is intended as a lesson to ‘encourage the others’ as Voltaire put it.
I’m not sure how the transfer to Louisiana could be remotely legal. AFAIK (and IANAL) the hearings must occur in the same jurisdiction or nearby because Khalil has a right to an attorney. Even revoking the green card (if it really happened before, which I doubt) is subject to the 14th Amendment review process. The whole process smacks of how the British shanghaied of colonists to London for show trials around the Revolution.
Over and over with the projection. If the fools could ever listen to themselves they would know the enemy of the state. I think cutting humanitarian funding to troubled regions around the world should easily qualify as “supporting terrorism”. The clowns can’t even properly do a connect-the-dots picture, let aloe paint-by-numbers or coloring within the lines.
I wonder if those “warrants” they flashed weren’t their Proud Boys IDs.
Apparently Pramila Jayapol is planning to hold non-violence trainings, virtual and in person. A bold move! I hope there will be more of this!
Last name is Jayapal. Yes, more of this — it demonstrates on her part foresight. I hope community organizers take note and follow her lead because we can expect this kind of training to be essential based on past experience.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pramila_Jayapal
https://ballotpedia.org/Pramila_Jayapal
https://www.congress.gov/member/pramila-jayapal/J000298
EW – you are correct, this feels like a fallback to the Dubya era, when anyone who is adjacent to something related to “terrorism” is denied due process and their Fifth Amendment rights go out the window. This really is a trial case – if judges let this illegal arrest and detention stand, there will be many more. Call your Senator and Rep. and tell them to stand tough against this crap!