Pay2Play Ceci: “The Most Influential Players” Love MaxTax

Pay2Play Ceci Connolly has an article out summing up the reaction she’s seeing to Max Baucus’ health care plan:

As they scoured the 223-page document, many of the most influential players found elements to dislike, but not necessarily reasons to kill the effort. Most enticing was the prospect of 30 million new customers.

In order of appearance, here are the people she cites in her article (I’ve bolded the ones she has actual quotes from):

  • Max Baucus
  • Obama
  • Liberal Democrats and allies, particularly labor unions
  • Republicans
  • Major industry leaders and interest groups
  • White House strategists
  • Obama
  • John D. Rockefeller
  • Lawmakers and lobbyists
  • Ron Wyden
  • Neil Trautwein, a vice president of the National Retail Federation
  • Leaders of the Business Roundtable and the National Federation of Independent Business
  • Drugmakers and hospitals
  • Kenneth E. Thorpe, an Emory University professor and Clinton administration official (noting that health care providers stand to make more than they’ll lose)
  • Max Baucus
  • Several trade associations
  • The medical device industry (dsecribed "recruiting" four senators to roll back fees on its industry)
  • One White House aide

In all, Ceci presents a landscape in which the most important players–aside from two Senators who have been slighted in the process thus far–are trade industry groups. And the most important issue for them is the profit they stand to make off of taxing America’s middle class to make them wealthier.

Now, to be fair to Pay2Play Ceci, that’s unashamedly the point of her article–that while the bill has pissed off Democrats and Republicans, it has thus far lulled the industry with dreams of forthcoming riches.

But behind the rhetorical fireworks was a sense that the fragile coalition of major industry leaders and interest groups central to refashioning the nation’s $2.5 trillion health-care system remains intact.

And also to be fair to Pay2Play Ceci, it’s clear that these players were the prime movers behind this bill. The story is absolutely accurate–though that doesn’t mean it has any business being told.

Nothing demonstrates the degree to which actual politicians–much less their constituents–have become mere bystanders as the health care industry crafts up a plan to get 30 million new captive customers.

One more point on this (so I can count this as my daily thrashing of the WaPo). An article like this is the natural outcome of the WaPo’s attempt to be a broker of the key players (not surprisingly, the same industry hacks highlighted here) in the health care debate. From the time Katharine Weymouth first recruited Pay2Play Ceci to invite her clients sources to the Pay2Play salons, it pretty much guaranteed that Pay2Play Ceci would come in at precisely this moment and present the industry’s judgment–that they’d be perfectly happy getting 30 million new customers with almost no payback–as "news."

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Reddit0Share on Facebook0Google+0Email to someone

140 Responses to Pay2Play Ceci: “The Most Influential Players” Love MaxTax

Emptywheel Twitterverse
emptywheel @nickconfessore That means it wouldn't take much of an unforeseen event to make convention wisdom wrong. @Atrios
emptywheel @nickconfessore I didn't judge primary wrong. I think demographically Hillary should not lose BUT her negatives are really high @Atrios
bmaz @WerlySportsLaw See, this is why he wears a gas mask. It is the allergies!
bmaz Smart and spot on response to Kevin Drum-----> "Stop sneering at Bernie Sanders"
bmaz @WALLACHLEGAL Yeah, and, really, even among appellate judges, who doesn't want to see Olson versus Clement?!?!
bmaz @emptywheel Yeah, but the tix for Pats game are EXPENSIVE! And I have a well known policy of never paying to see the Cardinals. We'll see!
emptywheel @bmaz You WANTED the stadium assignment. What changed?
bmaz @emptywheel Dang, I thought I was getting the courthouse assignment!
emptywheel RT @Laurapitter: At bottom of @jessicaschulb's story, Edelweiss says Mitchell's book “postponed indefinitely.” That'd be interesting. https…
bmaz @RMFifthCircuit Don't be a sour lemon drop Raffi, we need this to keep going!
emptywheel @bmaz I didn't mean for the courthouse I meant for the game.
emptywheel @astepanovich I JUST checked and said, it must be beer-thirty already. I'd say we have a quorum, in any case.
September 2009
« Aug   Oct »