What Kind of Custody Is It When You Secretly Hold an American at a Military Base?

Here’s a fairly minor point about the Gregory Saathoff report on Manssor Arbabsiar, the Scary Iran Plotter.

For the 12 day period when he was being secretly interrogated without a lawyer, he was being held at a military base.

Although at times Mr. Arbabsiar smoked inside the room, he often was escorted outside and on at least one occasion took a walk with agents around the military base.

Let me be clear: Arbabsiar’s arrest was approved by a US Magistrate. He was clearly arrested under civilian law.

And I’m not surprised the government held the cousin of a Quds Force member on a military base while they prepared to make an international incident out of his case. I’m sure Arbabsiar was nowhere near the first American citizen interrogated while in civilian custody at a military base.

But it’s coupled with the other part of this where it begins to get unsavory: the part where Arbabsiar had no lawyer and his legal team is now contesting whether he legally waived his right to a lawyer and presentment (and as I’ll explain if I ever get around to writing that post, I think their claim may have more merit than I originally did). And the part where the government didn’t check in with the Magistrate or have Arbabsiar medically examined until a week after he had been arrested.

So if the defense arguments about coerced waivers hold up (remember, we’re still seeing just part of what they’re complaining about), while a busy Magistrate knew he was in custody, Arbabsiar was otherwise in a black hole on a military base (though likely a quite pleasant one, with his own apartment) for a week to 12 days.

During the debate about the NDAA, people insisted we would never see a hybrid kind of detention where US citizens get indefinitely held, but in civilian custody. That’s not what happened to Arbabsiar; again, his detention had been approved by a Magistrate. But we are clearly inching closer to that kind of hybrid.

Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Reddit0Share on Facebook0Google+0Email to someone

33 Responses to What Kind of Custody Is It When You Secretly Hold an American at a Military Base?

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • 21
  • 22
  • 23
  • 24
  • 25
  • 26
  • 27
  • 28
  • 29
  • 30
  • 31
  • 32
  • 33
Emptywheel Twitterverse
emptywheel @josephfcox And they still haven't IDed the two who used fake passports.
emptywheel @josephfcox Except one of them was thinking additional attacks.
emptywheel @Ethan_Booker Harbaugh swore he was going to raise the standards for them (except for being nice to his wife). No evidence of that tho.
emptywheel @downi94 They seem to be prepared to test that.
emptywheel @dandrezner Putin's an expert on sanctions that will do exactly nothing, having been on receiving end of them.
emptywheel @csoghoian This is why USG is careful not to have technologists in agencies that get to boss Congress around.
emptywheel @konklone We're likely to find Paris attackers used breakable Telegram that served mostly to make metadata less accessible. @csoghoian
emptywheel @konklone I've been donning surveillance hawk hat & arguing USG would be better off if everyone used iPhone w/access to metadata. @csoghoian
emptywheel Spouse went out and got @fieldandfiregr croissants for our turkey sammiches. Living. #GoBlue
emptywheel @theurbansherpa Well then he better not fumble.
emptywheel How can the team w/a TE named Butt not win this game? #WasntMeantToBeDirty #GetYourMindOutOfTheGutter
emptywheel @theurbansherpa If they even understand it.
October 2012
« Sep   Nov »