Ron Wyden Calls Bullshit on Mike Rogers’ Claims

Mike Rogers, in an effort to defend his efforts to approve and hide dragnet collection on all Americans for years, claimed today that the dragnet prevented a terrorist attack.

“Within the last few years, this program was used to stop a terrorist attack in the United States. We know that. It’s important. It fills in a little seam that we have,” Rogers told reporters Thursday. ”And it’s used to make sure that there is not an international nexus to any terrorism event if there may be one ongoing. So in that regard, it is a very valuable thing,” Rogers said.

When pressed later for more details, Rogers said the committee is “working on trying to get this declassified in a way that we can provide more information. We’re not there yet. But it was a significant case that happened within the last few years.”

Get this: Rogers’ defense argues it makes sense to conduct dragnet surveillance of 310 million Americans for 7 years (plus the 5 years Bush did so illegally), all to thwart one terrorist plot.

One. Plot.

21 million person-years of call data collected since 2006.

One plot.

In his statement, Ron Wyden is a lot more skeptical that this program is so valuable.

The American people have a right to know whether their government thinks that the sweeping, dragnet surveillance that has been alleged in this story is allowed under the law and whether it is actually being conducted. Furthermore, they have a right to know whether the program that has been described is actually of value in preventing attacks. Based on several years of oversight, I believe that its value and effectiveness remain unclear.

Hey, I’d say that one plot over 7 years — especially when you consider how many banksters have done trillions of damage while FBI and NSA have been fiddling with the call records of innocent people — is the definition of a waste of time and resources.

Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Reddit0Share on Facebook0Google+3Email to someone

13 Responses to Ron Wyden Calls Bullshit on Mike Rogers’ Claims

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
Emptywheel Twitterverse
JimWhiteGNV RT @tparsi: 1/2 Many opponents of #IranDeal have called for war, but say Obama's fearmongering when he calls them out. @Cirincione @rezaasl
JimWhiteGNV RT @tparsi: 2/2 None of #IranDeal supporters have called for another holocaust, yet they're accused of that by same folks who accuse Obama …
emptywheel @TedLott It's a good thing those fuckers aren't more competent or we'd be in a heap of trouble.
JimWhiteGNV And so it begins. Lots of house renovations to take place over the next several weeks. First up: pavers on footpath to barn.
JimWhiteGNV Afghan civilian casualty figures for first half of year highest since 2009
emptywheel RT @mla1396: NEW: #OPMHack Notification Contract Released. 'Estimate for MINOR CHILDREN Impacted is 6.4 MILLION'
emptywheel @mla1396 Isn't the bigger question why this is still about identity theft?
emptywheel RT @Carter_PE: Bios for George Duchak & RADM Brian Hendrickson - DoD's new envoys to Silicon …
emptywheel @daveweigel "Straw-manny and cherry-picky"? That ought to go on your business cards.
emptywheel @konklone But thanks for doing the post. I hope @benjaminwittes listens to you. I adopted HTTPS bc it was only responsible thing for readers
emptywheel @konklone Lawfare has an obligation to encrypt bc its reader base are far too lucrative targets to leave exposed like that @benjaminwittes
emptywheel @konklone I might take this tweet and say w/o it you're exposing those "actually do" to adversaries @benjaminwittes
June 2013
« May   Jul »