Richard Clarke Alludes to the Real Costs of the Dragnet

New America Foundation did a study of 225 terrorist plots to try to discern the source of the investigation. There are numerous obvious flaws to the study — many of which stem from the government’s own efforts to obscure the sources of what they do, some of which stem from a lack of awareness about how the government responded to other tips by collecting more NSA intelligence, some of which stem from ignoring the dragnet that existed in illegal form before the FISC-approved one.

With those caveats, NAF finds what has been reported for months: only the Basaaly Moalin’s provision of less than $10,000 to al-Shabaab stemmed from the phone dragnet.

Which provides the WaPo with another opportunity to report this as news. I’ll take it: any little bit helps!

WaPo and NAF also report what I reported 5 months ago: that the government delayed 2 months after identifying Moalin’s ties indirectly to Aden Ayro before wiretapping him. Remember, they say they need the dragnet to avoid delays in investigation.

Perhaps the most interesting part of WaPo’s report on this, though, are Richard Clarke’s comments. As a follow-up on the NSA Review Group’s comment on the risk to quality of life posed by the dragnet, Clarke claims the dragnet would still be too intrusive if it had contributed to every plot.

“Although we might be safer if the government had ready access to a massive storehouse of information about every detail of our lives, the impact of such a program on the quality of life and on individual freedom would simply be too great,” the group’s report said.

Said Clarke: “Even if NSA had solved every one of the [terrorist] cases based on” the phone collection, “we would still have proposed the changes.”

This is actually a fairly stunning comment (and not one, I suspect, Mike Morell, who is also quoted, would support). Even if the dragnet had identified every potential terrorist plot, Clarke says, it would still be too intrusive.

I think the dragnet is plenty intrusive — and I think plenty of the ways it infringes on privacy are those not accounted in NAF’s analysis (such as the use of the dragnet to pick targets for informants or conduct back door searches). Still: to suggest the dragnet would not be worth every single one of these leads?

Tweet about this on Twitter3Share on Reddit0Share on Facebook3Google+1Email to someone

10 Responses to Richard Clarke Alludes to the Real Costs of the Dragnet

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10

Emptywheel Twitterverse
bmaz @cody_k Heh, not sure I'm gonna consign Zirin to the Cesca dump yet, but jeez for guy that bellows a lot on the net, he sure is thin skinned
10mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @chinahand Something gave KSA a great deal of success owning us after the Arab Spring. Dunno what it is, but they've got us by the nuts.
10mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PogoWasRight @davidrook Good point!
37mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @riversidesam What?? Golly Sam, thanks for all your brilliant non-linear (whatever that is) input. It was swell while it lasted!
38mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel RT @TimothyS: Fact: Ex-DIRNSA Hayden is on Motorola's board. "Second contractor protests FBI’s no-bid, $500m deal with Motorola." http://t.…
42mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @chinahand Which focus came, in significant part, at the behest of the Saudis.
48mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @PogoWasRight @davidrook Arrrgghh! I slept through it; will have to catch the repeat that starts in a couple of hours. Was it good?
49mreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV RT @TimothyS: Fact: Ex-DIRNSA Hayden is on Motorola's board. "Second contractor protests FBI’s no-bid, $500m deal with Motorola." http://t.…
52mreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV RT @barryeisler: Even though Hagel wants us hiding under our beds from “apocalyptic” ISIS, FBI says “no credible threats” @Antiwarcom http:…
1hreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV RT @carolrosenberg: From last night: #Guantanamo nurse who refused to force-feed may face court martial. http://t.co/rP9NzXqGFe @MiamiHerald
2hreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV RT @dravazed: RT - FBI Admits: No Credible Threats to US From ISIS http://t.co/5h34hpjsjF we knew that
2hreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV @WinWithoutWar @SPMiles42 Congrats! Keep up the great work.
2hreplyretweetfavorite