Stanely McChrystal

Is David Petraeus Leaking to Undercut the President? Or Is Someone Framing Him?

The WaPo has the latest in seemingly yearly series of leaks of Top Secret cables designed to undercut the President’s plan to withdraw from Afghanistan.

The U.S. ambassador to Afghanistan sent a top-secret cable to Washington last month warning that the persistence of enemy havens in Pakistan was placing the success of the U.S. strategy in Afghanistan in jeopardy, U.S. officials said.

The cable, written by Ryan C. Crocker, amounted to an admission that years of U.S. efforts to curtail insurgent activity in Pakistan by the lethal Haqqani network, a key Taliban ally, were failing.

The hints and feints the article offers about who leaked the memo provide ample entertainment for a Saturday afternoon.

Note the way the WaPo describes its sources inconsistently. It offers this quote from a senior defense official.

“The sanctuaries are a deal-killer for the [Afghan war] strategy,” said a senior defense official who is familiar with the ongoing debate and who, like several officials in this story, spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive internal deliberations. [my emphasis]

But then the WaPo suggests military leaders have motive to leak the cable, distinguishing between “defense” and “military” officials.

The cable, which was described by several officials familiar with its contents, could be used as ammunition by senior military officials who favor more aggressive action by the United States against the Haqqani havens in Pakistan. It also could buttress calls from senior military officials for a more gradual withdrawal of U.S. forces from Afghanistan as the 2014 deadline for ending combat operations approaches.

These military officials have maintained for months that the strategy of targeting raids against Taliban leadership and building local Afghan governance is showing impressive results. [my emphasis]

Mind you, none of these military officials seem to be directly quoted here–at least not defined as military officials. The comment might just reflect the knowledge of Greg Jaffe, WaPo’s military writer. Though it would be consistent if a General or two leaked such a cable–after all, Stanley McChrystal is assumed to have leaked a similar cable during Obama’s Afghanistan review in 2009, for similar reason.

Yet I’m most interested in this quote, of someone whose affiliation was rather pointedly (given the description of defense and military sources) not identified.

“There’s no debate about the importance of going after Haqqani . . . and Taliban militants who launch attacks into Afghanistan,” one U.S. official said. “Support for this is universal.” [my emphasis]

The article also defaults to “US officials” elsewhere, though that could be because the sources came from multiple agencies. Note, “US official” can be used to refer to members of Congress, as well as agency officials.

In any case should we assume these unmarked sources are intelligence ones–the beat of Greg Miller, the WaPo’s intelligence writer and the other byline on the story?

Continue reading

Emptywheel Twitterverse
emptywheel @jonahsilas I'll come fetch some, thanks. (or make spouse make the same, assuming you're not close)
emptywheel @jonahsilas I'd be okay to let Rye Whiskey be the thing (bc I drink neither) but one or another deserves notice, no?
emptywheel Win or lose I love how Martha Ford is becoming A Presence. In spite of what shithead DT columnists said abt girls owning football teams.
emptywheel RT @jonahsilas: @emptywheel Whiskey is a modern product. The pilgrims were more likely drinking something ale-like. Bourbon shows up in 180…
emptywheel @jonahsilas But it IS quintessentially American now isn't it? Bc branding?
emptywheel The special Thanksgiving episode of Real Housewives of NFC East delivered precisely what watchers expected.
emptywheel @zrahul2020 Really? In a non suckitude way? @SI_PeterKing
emptywheel It's quaint how in the UK when you seize info w/o a warrant the case falls apart.
emptywheel Seriously, I'm not a Bourbon drinker, but why ISN'T it a more formal part of Thanksgiving (as some in my TL have noted)?
emptywheel Imma have to write that Cam was a dick and lost his team and then learned how to be a leader article, aren't I?
emptywheel @LornestoToledo "barbarians," I think you meant. @BlueMeanie4
November 2015
« Oct