women’s rights

Future Forecast: Ignoring Half the Picture Yields Surprisingly Poor Results

[adapted: Magic 8-Ball by Andres Rueda via Flickr]

[Adapted: Magic 8-Ball by Andres Rueda via Flickr]

It’s that time of year when we not only take a look backward, but a look forward to the future. Unfortunately in doing so, we rely heavily on so-called experts, whose vision suffers from two fundamental limitations:

  • They’re overwhelmingly male; their viewpoints are published more frequently than those of women;
  • They depend frequently on male-dominated science and technology in constructing their forecasts, rather than looking at shifts in human conditions.

Once a upon a time in my career, I rubbed shoulders with futurists, both in corporate visioning and in business intelligence. They made a few eye-opening predictions that I pooh-poohed at the time. In 1999 one futurist told me that fuel cell technology wouldn’t be commercialized for more than 10 or 15 years. Another report circa 2000 predicted the U.S. would become a rogue nation because of its hegemonic power.

I laughed off both of those forecasts at the time. You’ll note, however, none of our government’s unilaterally killing drones use fuel cells as power sources.

In spite of the occasional spot-on prediction, many of the forecasts I’ve read or seen made as part of scenario planning have not come to pass. They remain years and decades away if they haven’t already become impossible or irrelevant. Why are future outcomes so notoriously nebulous?

During the dozen-plus years since I first worked with futurists and participated in scenario planning sessions, I’ve wised up and learned a few things, key to understanding the lameness of most futurists’ forecasts.

1) It’s really difficult for most organizations to see outside their own self-constructed silos built on the expertise of their products and services. They hire and promote subject-matter experts and look to them for forecasts. Because of internal feedback loops, organizations become blind to barriers so that their members really can’t see with specificity beyond 2-5 years. Asking folks in formal organizations to make forecasts about their own work, even with well-trained facilitators, is extremely difficult. Barriers within their own organizations may be invisible to them as well, ex. internal politics, or other activities deliberately hidden from view.

2) Organizations are often blind to their own social capital. If members within groups are uniformly unchallenged by barriers within and without their business lives, they may not see bumps in the road that thwart everybody else outside their group.

3) Outsiders who speculate on future activities of organizations while relying on publicly available information from within these groups may suffer from the same siloed and blinkered vision.

4) Predictions tend to follow the quantifiable, where the money as well as expectation exist—in science and technology. Unfortunately, scientists are loathe to make guarantees; they give percentages and odds, but not absolute assurances. Forecasts are only as good as the current understanding of science and technology, within some margin of error. Futurists often round up, encouraging excessive optimism.

These factors may explain why futurists’ predictions may ignore realities that grip nearly half of the humans on earth, while rendering so many of their forecasts inert.

Even factoring in the biases that shape forecasts, the future imagined can be far too tidy, . The gritty truths of the human condition and all its volatility are too neatly removed, parceled off outside the field of speculation. Continue reading

Emptywheel Twitterverse
bmaz @lilsarg @GenePeyroux ...and grew up next door to an older girl who was one of last wave of polio victims. Can't fathom not vaccinating.
2mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @lilsarg @GenePeyroux Wow, did not see that back when you first posted it, but thanks for writing it. I had chicken pox and measles as a kid
4mreplyretweetfavorite
bmaz @lilsarg @GenePeyroux In a family of fully vaccinated people in a, hopefully community of fully vaccinated people. Who trust science.
24mreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel RT @chinahand: Working title for my AT piece on pivot http://t.co/BJvLEp8qz0 Global Hegemon Seeks Local Assistance for West Pacific D*ck Me…
1hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @sbagen A radical shift in policy as we move from the second Dingell tenure to the third!
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel If only we had CISA, it would prevent these people from killing the Toobz by cutting fibers. http://t.co/4kljAqnubI
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @xor Don't do it!!! @normative bought me a drink that once and I've been tainted ever since.
2hreplyretweetfavorite
JimWhiteGNV @20newsguy Don't you know? The most important issue today is whether to put peas into guacamole!
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @pjfleischer Maybe. But my eggplant plants aren't growing. The orphan tomatoes are about to take over their entire bed.
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel MI has cold mid-summer weather & horribly abusive prisons, but none of your states have Colbert on public access. http://t.co/WLXfdcjh82
2hreplyretweetfavorite
emptywheel @Popehat You starting a new spoof account there?
2hreplyretweetfavorite
July 2015
S M T W T F S
« Jun    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031