In Dismissing Georgia RICO Case, Peter Skandalakis Fabricates Jack Smith Conclusion

I am not surprised that Peter Skandalakis asked to dismiss the Georgia prosecution against Donald Trump. The fault for its dismissal lies primarily with Fani Willis for giving him the opportunity to dismiss it.

But Skandalakis’ dismissal is dishonest in many places and outright false in one case: notably, in his claim that Jack Smith concluded that he could not prosecute the case after SCOTUS interfered.

The strongest and most prosecutable case against those seeking to overturn the 2020 Presidential election results and prevent the certification of those votes was the one investigated and indicted by Special Counsel Jack Smith. Although Special Counsel JackSmith’s federal case encompassed evidence from multiple states, he ultimately concluded the federal case could not be prosecuted because of the U. S. Supreme Court’s decision in Trump v. United States and the re-election of President Donald J. Trump.

Special Counsel Jack Smith wrote in his report, “Conversely, a select few of Mr. Trump’s agents and elector nominees had insight into the ultimate plan to use the fraudulent elector certificates to disrupt the congressional certification on January 6 and willingly assisted…. In each of the targeted states, Mr. Trump and his co-conspirators successfully organized enough elector nominees and substitutes to gather on December 14, cast fraudulent electoral votes on his behalf, and send them to Washington, D.C., for the congressional certification.”28

The criminal conduct alleged in the Atlanta Judicial Circuit’s prosecution was conceived in Washington, D.C., not the State of Georgia. The federal government is the appropriate venue for this prosecution, not the State of Georgia. Indeed, if Special Counsel Jack Smith, with all the resources of the federal government at his disposal, after reviewing the evidence in this case and considering the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Trump v.United States, along with the years of litigation such a case would inevitably entail, concluded that prosecution would be fruitless, then I too find that, despite the available evidence, pursuing the prosecution of all those involved in State of Georgia v. DonaldTrump, et al. on essentially federal grounds would be equally unproductive.

The evidence had nothing to do with Smith’s decision to drop the case when Trump was reelected. Indeed, before the election he had laid out how he still planned to do so, as he laid out in his immunity brief.

This motion provides a comprehensive account of the defendant’s private criminal conduct; sets forth the legal framework created by Trump for resolving immunity claims; applies that framework to establishthat none of the defendant’s charged conduct is immunized because it either was unofficial or anypresumptive immunity is rebutted; and requests the relief the Government seeks, which is, at bottom, this: that the Court determine that the defendant must stand trial for his private crimes as would any other citizen.

This was a cowardly and partisan dodge by Skandalakis, one that sacrifices the integrity of Georgia’s democracy.

image_print
Share this entry
19 replies
  1. Rugger_9 says:

    GA is solidly red in the statehouse, and would be using the top-line conclusion (can’t prosecute…) and left off the why (…now until Convict-1 is out of office due to SCOTUS immunity).

    They will reap what they’ve sown because Convict-1 won’t protect them later.

  2. P J Evans says:

    It was pretty clear that this would be the result when they removed the prosecutor for unconnected reasons.

  3. BRUCE F COLE says:

    This was a cowardly, partisan and *dumfoundingly dishonest* dodge. Everyone knows Smith was compelled by events, not evidence, to drop the case that SCOTUS left him with. Skadiddle is practicing Trumpism to a tee.

    Maybe the asshole is pitching for a federal bench slot. I wondered what was up when he didn’t dismiss the case after Fani’s fadeaway finale; maybe now we know why: so he could lob that big fat pitch!

    • BRUCE F COLE says:

      But the hits are not in one direction, even those initiated by these fascist bastards, not by a long shot. This, for instance, could go viral, with chapter and verse ala Marcy.

  4. Molly Pitcher says:

    There has been a shooting in DC, two West Virginia National Guard have been shot, the suspect has also been ‘gravely’ injured and is in custody at the hospital. Reagan National Airport was briefly shut down to allow for a medivac helicopter for all three.

    The shooting took place on H, in downtown, a couple blocks from the White House. It was near a subway/Metro entrance, and the glass from a bus stop is scattered all over the sidewalk.

    No other information is available yet.

    • Matt___B says:

      The only additional info I’ve heard (from BBC) is that the governor of WV erroneously reported that the 2 NG were dead and minutes later retracted that saying “condition unknown” due to conflicting reports…

    • Ginevra diBenci says:

      Suspect is Afghan national who entered US under Biden’s (righteous, in my view) policy helping those who had helped us during the wars. This will provide all kinds fodder for Trump and MAGA to scream “terrorism” and “Biden’s fault.”

      I pray that the two Guardsmen survive, but also that the suspect survives so he can tell us himself why this happened instead of having Kash Patel and Jeanine Pirro scream their version at us, as they are doing right now.

      Mayor Bowser continues to impress with her thoughtfulness and restraint, qualities sadly lacking in the Trump administration.

      • Leslie_27NOV2025_1336h says:

        They can scream all they want, but it was the Trump administration that granted him asylum in April of this year.

        [Welcome to emptywheel. Please choose and use a unique username with a minimum of 8 letters. We adopted this minimum standard to support community security. Because your username is too short and common, your username will be temporarily changed to match the date/time of your first known comment until you have a new compliant username. /~Rayne]

      • Rugger_9 says:

        In 2021, the GOP was harrumphing loudly in the media about how Joe was abandoning the Afghan interpreters to their fates and failed to plan for their extraction. As I noted some time ago in another thread regarding the Kabul attack, the withdrawal was put in motion by the first Convict-1 administration with firm deadlines for actions, in addition to closing Bagram unilaterally. The latter action ensured that Kabul airport would be the funnel for departures and it was far less secure than Bagram air base. It was a perfect setup for a gauntlet that was blamed on Biden but if he delayed things the local maniacs would have made assymmetric warfare when we had insufficient troops (thanks to Convict-1’s Doha agreement) to protect the perimeter. This background is important to understand why the courtier press continues to sanewash GOP hypocrisy.

        So, Biden vetted in as many Afghans as he could because those left behind are likely all long-dead now. Not just waved in, but vetted with multiple reviews by DoD and CIA, et al. Convict-1’s administration approved the alleged shooter’s asylum claim in April 2025, but that didn’t stop the NYT from claiming this was a ‘Biden asylum case’ even though it was Convict-1’s WH that approved it. If Biden owns Bagram, Convict-1 owns the DC shooting and NYT needs to be unbiased.

        Someday, there will need to be an investigation into why the NYT really hated Ds so much that their animus oozed into their stories and they actually employed RW moles as ‘reporters’ without any curiousity regarding why their reporting kept getting fact-checked and debunked.

    • Zinsky123 says:

      Still recovering from turkey-induced coma but this story out of Georgia is particularly galling because it removes any hope of bringing the Orange Monster to justice in a state court – at least any time soon! I completely agree with your suggestion for a Judicial Hall of Shame with an entire wing devoted to the judicial abominations that Trump created or that helped create him! From Roy Cohn to Rudy Giuliani to John Roberts to Aileen Cannon to Alina Habba to now Lindsay Halligan – the corruption, incompetence and treachery of this bunch of criminals is astounding!

Comments are closed.