Close, But No Cigar: NYPD within 3 Miles of Faisal Shahzad’s Hawala, Missed It

On April 10, 2010, Mohammad Younis, of Centereach, NY, met with Faisal Shahzad at the Ronkonkoma train station and gave him $7,000 in cash. That money went to buy fertilizer, propane, and gasoline that Shahzad used to build a bomb he tried to set off in Times Square three weeks later–the last real Islamic terrorist attack launched on New York City.

I was particularly interested to see the NYPD’s intelligence profile of Suffolk County released by the AP this morning. As I noted last year, the NYPD’s extensive intelligence programs failed to identify the two most significant attacks on NY in recent history: those attempted by Najibullah Zazi and Shahzad.

With Zazi, that failure was epic; the NYPD used his imam as an informant, and actually tipped Zazi off to the investigation.

But Shahzad’s attack would have been harder to find. He plotted the attack from Connecticut–outside the city, though well within the range of the NYPD’s intelligence efforts. The one lead squarely within the NYPD’s profiling activities, though, would have been the hawala Shahzad used–Younis’ hawala–to get money from Pakistan.

It turns out the NYPD’s profiling efforts got within 3 miles of Younis’ house. They profiled his house of worship, the Islamic Association of Long Island. They profiled about 10 businesses in his community–though they focused on the halal restaurants, not the 7-11 where Younis used to work or the Lowes where he worked at the time he met with Shahzad. They also profiled a mosque and an auto repair shop in Ronkonkoma, the town where Shahzad met with Younis.

They never found Younis or his hawala activities, which he did not operate for profit.

Mind you, even if they had profiled the 7-11 or the Lowes, they still wouldn’t have found anything. Younis himself had no knowledge of Shahzad’s plot (Younis plead guilty to one count of unlicensed money remitting and was sentenced to three years of probation in December).

Which all goes to show that even profiling the precise neighborhoods through which terrorist money flows will not–did not–serve to discover or prevent attacks.

Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Reddit0Share on Facebook0Google+0Email to someone

5 Responses to Close, But No Cigar: NYPD within 3 Miles of Faisal Shahzad’s Hawala, Missed It

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Emptywheel Twitterverse
bmaz @Pachacutec_ Dude. Seriously? Would very much have liked that.
bmaz @Pachacutec_ Lasorda is an ass. But ya gotta love Da Bums!
bmaz @Pachacutec_ Gibby was the best!
emptywheel Going to bed, but so looking forward to writing abt this Ornstein opinion.
emptywheel Magistrate judges are sexy. No matter what you've been taught.
emptywheel RT @csoghoian: Pro-tip: When seeking an order forcing Apple to subvert its own security, cite as authority part of the Judiciary Act of 178…
emptywheel @jilliancyork EFF has been blocked in past. @united
emptywheel @BuffyBlogs Hopefully I and others can do justice but it's an exuberant flag.
emptywheel Don't think I can finish Ornstein analysis until tomorrow AM but I am smooching him, make no mistake.
emptywheel So basically this Apple story is abt judge shopping magistrates.
emptywheel @marciahofmann If you can say how did this become public (since as far as I can get docket is still sealed)?
emptywheel "Hospital Hero" Jim Comey slinks around asking for things Admin says it won't ask for.
February 2012
« Jan   Mar »