Perhaps Stephen Miller (Also) Believes in the Efficacy of a Deportation Gulag as a Tool to Usher in Fascism
Like me, Greg Sargent continues to focus on the messaging opportunities presented by recent developments in Stephen Miller’s deportation gulag. (In the wake of NYT’s coverage and Sargent’s interview with Carol Hui the other day, Hui has been released from detention.)
This post reacts to this NBC story which, in turn, follows up on the Washington Examiner (!!!) story reporting on Miller’s recent meltdown about the number of deportations. NBC added to the story about Miller’s meltdown by pointing to how Trump has shifted law enforcement’s focus from their day jobs — hunting child sex traffickers, hackers, spies, and terrorists — to instead hunt peaceful undocumented migrants.
It is the latest example of how President Donald Trump’s push for mass deportations is reshaping federal law enforcement as officials shift resources toward immigration-related cases — including nonviolent administrative offenses — leaving less time and attention for other types of criminal investigations.
The plan calls for using 3,000 ICE agents, including 1,800 from Homeland Security Investigations, which generally investigates transnational crimes and is not typically involved in arresting noncriminal immigrants; 2,000 Justice Department employees from the FBI, the U.S. Marshals Service and the Drug Enforcement Administration; and 500 employees from Customs and Border Protection. It also includes 250 IRS agents, some of whom may be used to provide information on the whereabouts of immigrants using tax information, while others would have the authority to make arrests, according to the operation plan.
Sargent argues that if Democrats (I would argue, Trump opponents generally) can explain how Trump is making the country less safe to hunt down people like Carol Hui, they’ll grow even more opposed to Miller’s deportation gulag.
It’s a good point — similar to the one I made about the extent to which Miller’s jihad is depriving Americans of cancer cures. There are a bunch of opportunity costs that come with Miller’s deportation gulag, including hunting child sex traffickers and curing cancer. All of them are bad. We need to tell that story.
Along the way to making that point, though, Sargent makes this claim about Miller’s beliefs. Miller believes, Sargent argues, that migrants poison the nation’s blood. He believes hunting down people like Carol Hui is an emergency.
Unlike Miller, that is, majorities are not ideologically hostile to the mere presence of peaceful unauthorized immigrants in this country; they just want the system to work. Yet Miller and Trump see that presence as itself posing a dire public emergency, or even a civilizational one. In this worldview, there can be no desirable pathway to lawful status here for these people, because they inherently represent a public threat—they are “poisoning” the nation’s “blood.” Making them legal wouldn’t change that. It would only make the threat they pose more insidious.
That’s why Miller is capable of tweeting that the House GOP budget bill is the “most essential piece of legislation” in “the entire Western World,” largely because it ramps up deportation resources. To him, saving the “Western World” rides on deporting all those unauthorized people, including all those “moms.”
All this gets at the deeper reason Miller and Trump are shifting extensive law enforcement resources away from serious crimes into deporting noncriminal immigrants: They simply do see the presence of these people as an extraordinarily urgent national emergency, perhaps more urgent than all those other serious crimes.
I want to suggest that Miller’s unrelenting obsession with his deportation gulag may be more than just uncontrolled racism (though I have no doubt it is that, at least).
When you shift law enforcement from the FBI to DHS, you do more than simply shift law enforcement from focusing on child sex traffickers, hackers, spies, and terrorists to focusing on nice ladies like Carol Hui.
You also shift from a law enforcement that must meet increasing evidentiary standards — first probable cause and then beyond a reasonable doubt — to jail people, to one that has a far more lower threshold, one that affords the claims of the Executive great deference. And even in that context, Miller keeps looking for ways to lower the burden of law enforcement still lower; that’s the reason he pursued his Alien Enemies Act project: because he believes and wants Judges to get no review of such deportations. Next up, Miller wants to eliminate habeas corpus, such that the Executive could detain anyone with no judicial review.
Shifting from the FBI, which must adhere to written rules developed over decades in the wake of past abuses, to DHS, frees you from a great many strictures on how you investigate people. (This would be one effect of making ICE a bigger law enforcement agency than FBI.)
Shifting from FBI to DHS shifts you from a legalized culture to thug culture.
And Stephen Miller has never hid that he wants to apply this abusive law enforcement approach to US citizens to. He’s just not sure how he’ll get there.
Miller explicitly wants to be able to jail and deport people — and he has swept up legal aliens and even American citizens — without any review. That’s the goal. False inflammatory claims about immigration is the means.
I would suggest that Miller’s fondness for deportation gulags is about more than racism (though, again, it is definitely about racism). Miller’s false claims about immigrants are the means he plans to use to lower or eliminate the legal protections that all people in America — citizen and migrant alike — have against abusive Executive power.
Stephen Miller both believes in white supremacy but also that the United States should eliminate due process for all enemies of Donald Trump.
Spot on, EW. In some more rational future civilization the question of why Stephen Miller turned out this way and in de facto power needs to be explored because if it happened once it can happen again.
“…if it happened once”? Setting aside the many prior instances marring human history (written and, damningly, often un-), we have one glaring example of when it DID happen once. Recently. As in: less than a century ago.
Stephen Miller is Jewish. I don’t know whether he’s practicing. But he sure as hell should know the history of racist pogroms. We all should.
Stephen Miller has made a close study of state oppression, including German and Russian pogroms against the Jews. Thing is, he takes the view of the oppressor, and studies them for textbook examples of how to successfully oppress in order to maintain and enhance state power. Another keen interest is in enhancing the power of the chief executive, for whom he and Russell Vought are alter egos.
“It can happen again” Been Jewish all my life and I see it all the time, maybe that’s just the way the matzoh crumbles; into a half-baked cracker.
It’s stunning to see just how feral Miller is now. I don’t know if he ever was liked, perhaps to a point similar to how serial killers get in terms of grievance.
Like Trump and like Musk, Stephen Miller isn’t similar to serial killers. Stephen Miller IS a serial killer. By now his depredations have surely cost lives, about which he could not care less. That is killing, whether you hire out the death-dealing or not.
Speaking of Miller, I’ve been Jewish all my life, and all too often, that’s just how the matzoh crumbles; into a half-baked cracker.
[Welcome back to emptywheel. Please choose and use a unique username with a minimum of 8 letters. We have adopted this minimum standard to support community security. Your username is too short; because you have less than 1000 comments published and been participating less than 10 years as of October 2022, your username will not be grandfathered under the old standard. Your username will be temporarily changed to match the date/time of your first known comment until you have a new compliant username. Further more, you have either changed your email address since your last post in 2020, or you are not the same Mooser. Please use the same email address each time you comment here forward; we don’t even care if it’s a valid/working email address, only that it’s the same one each time. /~Rayne]
Will do, thx.
[Thanks for updating your username to meet the 8-letter minimum. Please be sure to use the same username and email address each time you comment so that community members get to know you. /~Rayne]
I wonder if Miller also believe in people falling out of windows after offending The Felon Guy.
Marcy,
Reporting truth to power with evidence compassion and humor is what you do. Thanks to all Emptywheel.net and readers. We are in this together. Peace.
Yogarhythms and family
Even if Miller gets his wish and all illegal immigrants were deported from the U.S. tomorrow, white people would still represent just over half of the population ( 58.2% – https://datausa.io/profile/geo/united-states#demographics ). Would Miller be happy then or would he turn on any non-whites that remained?
[Welcome back to emptywheel. Please use the SAME USERNAME and email address each time you comment so that community members get to know you. You attempted to publish this comment as “Dorian Melton” triggering auto-moderation; it has been edited to reflect your established username. Please check your browser’s cache and autofill; future comments may not publish if username does not match. /~Rayne]
Gee, Mr. Miller, what could “poison” America more than millions of Jews who stubbornly and peculiarly refuse to embrace the truth of Christ?
EW: “Miller’s false claims about immigrants are the means he plans to use to lower or eliminate the legal protections that all people in America — citizen and migrant alike — have against abusive Executive power.”
Indeed, undocumented immigrants are low hanging fruit. Their new, DOGEified ability to cross reference previously siloed federal databases lets the fruit hang even lower.
An “undocumented” status of a kind is likely to soon be imposed on trans people, whose post-transition identity documentation shows a sex and/or gender that differs from their birth certificate, or whose current name differs from the name originally linked to their SS#. Such individuals (including myself), are easily findable in the de-siloed data, and will be declared to be existing under a fraudulent identification, declared a security and cultural risk, and will be given the option of either correcting and updating their papers and records— to in effect be forced to legally de-transition — or risk being rounded up as an undocumented entity, regardless of citizenship.
Of course, I could just be catastrophizing. But it seems right in line with the “stunt” executive orders and the daily ante-upping thrills-n-chills from the show runners of Trump II.
I am afraid you are right. And I worry that the same is true of RFK jr’s idea for a database of autistic people, especially after his incredibly evil speech saying how pointless their existence is (because, “they’ll never pay taxes!”). And then the old and sick. After all, “we’re all going to die” and as Scrooge would say, better for them to die and so decrease the “surplus population”. (I have been thinking a lot about Scrooge lately.)
Trump, Miller and MAGA wants a police state and nobody is more MAGA than the police. A marriage made in heaven as they say.
The fascist dictatorship is definitely a dual project along with the deportation machine.
But, if the Big Brutal Bill passes, I can see the not too distant day when the deportation machine causes MAGA to revolt. The loss of waitresses, health care workers, construction, farm workers, etc … would create all sorts of low paid and hard work jobs to fill by people forced to work to get their medicaid. MAGAville will not be happy becoming indentured servants.
Along with food assistance taking a cut, food prices (especially due to lost labor) are very likely to rise. Then, combined with very low paid jobs for the unfortunate, we may have Americans eating the dogs.
Medicare/aid cuts would end up forcing the closures of many rural hospitals and senior care facilities that couldn’t survive without the federal funds. So now their mother in law is coming back home.
The Big Bill will bring major stressors from multiple directions that even Fox news can’t pin on Biden.
The backlash Miller and Trump would receive is likely another reason they want to pump up DHS and ICE into the American gestapo. They would need it if their plans are successful.
Let’s suppose Trump’s approval rating on October 1, 2025 is 25%. This is close to the floor of support afforded him by the sealed right wing media system. Let’s suppose too that the generic ballot is Dems +15. Let’s suppose the economy has been in a recession since September 1.
Will we then learn from leaks of Miller’s, (and Bannon’s?) plans for the midterm elections?
Happening NOW:
Ranking Member Jayapal Hosts Shadow Hearing on Unlawful Third County Disappearances [Link in Hawkins THREAD, below]
Katherine Hawkins live posting here:
https://bsky.app/profile/krhawkins.bsky.social/post/3lqwuipbqg22q
June 6, 2025 at 8:46 AM [Link][THREAD]
Also from Hawkins:
Stephen Miller v. the Rule of Law
Threats to habeas corpus are part of a larger pattern of attacks on the courts.
https://www.pogo.org/analysis/stephen-miller-v-the-rule-of-law
Katherine Hawkins June 4, 2025