Murder
In the last few days, we’ve got allegations of murder against two men who worked in counterinsurgency in Afghanistan, Whiskey Pete Hegseth and Rahmanullah Lakanwal.
We don’t yet know why Lakanwal drove from Bellingham, WA, across the country, to allegedly ambush two members of the West Virginia National Guard, Sarah Beckstrom and Andrew Wolfe. Spencer Ackerman noted that if Lakanwal came to the US committed to terrorism, he learned that commitment — and a great deal of military skills — from Americans.
[T]he most sobering fact about Wednesday’s slayings is that the alleged killer, Rahmanullah Lakanwal, was all too compatible with Western Civilization.
CIA Director John Ratcliffe issued an extraordinary statement revealing that the 29-year-old Lakanwal was a “member of a partner force in Kandahar.” While a knowledgeable source with deep experience in Afghanistan cautions that the US sponsored a variety of proxy forces in southern Afghanistan, much additional reporting has identified Lakanwal as a member of the Zero Units, death squads used by the CIA during the US’s longest overseas war.
In other words, contrary to Miller and Trump, Lakanwal’s shooting spree is not the result of importing Afghan culture to America. While much will surely be revealed in Lakanwal’s upcoming trial, it looks more like the result of importing American culture to Afghanistan. The realities of blowback – the violence America experiences as the unintended consequences of the violence of US foreign policy – are what the US needs to examine in the wake of this horrifying murder if it expects to prevent the next one.
But even Ackerman doesn’t consider the possibility that something happened since — quite possibly in the last year, as Trump keeps dicking around allies of all sorts who’ve helped the United States in the past — that led Lakanwal to drive across the country only to target members of the Guard who had been uprooted from their homes to avenge Ed “Big Balls” Coristine.
The list of Republican governors who will uproot Guardsmen from their home, family, and (for many of them) regular jobs to go to DC continues to grow:
- Ohio Governor Mike DeWine
- South Carolina Governor Henry McMaster
- West Virginia Governor Patrick Morrisey
- Tennessee Governor Bill Lee
- Mississippi Governor Tate Reeves
- Louisiana Governor Jeff Landry
All of these men believe protecting Big Balls is a higher priority than protecting their own constituents.
How soon we forget that the entire reason why Trump invaded DC is that Ed “Big Balls” Coristine, one of the DOGE boys hired by the richest man in the world to snoop through the private heath and social security data of Americans, got beat up by unarmed teenagers?
Contrary to what Trump and his propagandists keep squealing, Lakanwal was vetted over and over again.
The Afghan national accused of shooting two National Guard members near the White House this week underwent thorough vetting by counterterrorism authorities before entering the United States, according to people with direct knowledge of the case.
Rahmanullah Lakanwal, 29, arrived in the U.S. through Operation Allies Welcome (OAW), a Biden-era program that helped resettle Afghan nationals after the U.S. military withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021.
[snip]
A key question from critics has been whether any evacuees managed to enter the U.S. without proper vetting. Lakanwal, however, would not have been among them, according to the individuals, who requested anonymity because of the sensitivity of the investigation. One of the individuals said Lakanwal was vetted years ago, before working with the CIA in Afghanistan, and then again before he arrived in the U.S. in 2021. Those examinations involved both the National Counterterrorism Center as well as the CIA, the person said.
Lakanwal was also granted asylum earlier this year, a process that would have brought its own scrutiny, according to #AfghanEvac, a coalition that supported the relocation effort — an assertion the White House did not dispute.
But no amount of vetting can forestall every awful possibility of violence.
Similarly, we can’t even say what led our Crusader-tatted Secretary of Defense to personally order the murder of two men who survived the first murderboat operation on September 2.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth gave a spoken directive, according to two people with direct knowledge of the operation. “The order was to kill everybody,” one of them said.
A missile screamed off the Trinidad coast, striking the vessel and igniting a blaze from bow to stern. For minutes, commanders watched the boat burning on a live drone feed. As the smoke cleared, they got a jolt: Two survivors were clinging to the smoldering wreck.
The Special Operations commander overseeing the Sept. 2 attack — the opening salvo in the Trump administration’s war on suspected drug traffickers in the Western Hemisphere — ordered a second strike to comply with Hegseth’s instructions, two people familiar with the matter said. The two men were blown apart in the water.
Trump claims these murderboat operations combat drug trafficking. That was always suspect. Not only are many of the people killed at most low-level shippers, but killing traffickers was less useful than capturing them.
And Trump’s promise to pardon former President of Honduras, Juan Orlando Hernández, who was a major drug trafficker, suggests Trump is not so much opposed to drug trafficking, he just wants a cut.
What we do know about Hegseth, the man who ordered defenseless men to be murdered, is that the Fox News host repeatedly failed efforts to vet him — first when he was excluded from defending the Capitol after January 6, and then the multiple warnings of abuse, incompetence, and addiction reviewed during his confirmation process.
And so it was that Pete Hegseth happily uprooted Sarah Beckstrom from her home to serve as a prop for Trump’s authoritarian theater, where she was as predicted, targeted.
[M]ilitary commanders had warned that their deployment represented an easy “target of opportunity” for grievance-based violence. The troops, deployed in an effort to reduce crime, are untrained in law enforcement; their days are spent cleaning up trash and walking the streets in uniform. Commanders, in a memo that was included in litigation challenging the high-visibility mission in D.C., argued that this could put them in danger. The Justice Department countered that the risk was merely “speculative.” It wasn’t. There are costs to performatively deploying members of the military—one of which is the risk of endangering them.
Hegseth kept Beckstrom deployed even after Judge Jia Cobb ruled, six days before Beckstrom was shot, that state governors, including WV’s Patrick Morrisey, don’t have the authority to send their Guard to DC without being invited by DC.
[T]he out-of-state National Guards are likely operating in the District in a manner contrary to law. Under section 502(f), state law defines the permissible use of the National Guard under state control—i.e., which missions the governors can order their units to conduct. Here, the state governors whose units are currently operating in the District lack authority to order these missions because the District has not properly sought their aid under D.C. law and the EMAC.
This vetting failure, Pete Hegseth, happily obeyed Trump’s order to bring even more Guard troops to DC, whose mission of “crime deterrence and passive patrolling” will now require more Metropolitan Police Department effort to protect the Guard from being targeted again.
Two alleged murderers brought demons with them from Afghanistan to the US. Both together got a young woman with all her dreams and life ahead of her killed.
And yet we’re not removing the more obvious vetting problem to prevent further disasters.





OMG, thank you EW. Trump does not care about drug trafficking. “Drugs” are merely a pretext to throw around performative dominance: blabbing about force and then illegally killing people for no demonstrable reason. If he cared about drug trafficking one of his first acts in office would not have been pardoning Ross Ulbricht, the Silk Road proprietor who trafficked more drugs than any fisherman in a boat in the Caribbean could in a lifetime.
Trump is a terrorist (or wannabe) who needs to kill in order to maintain the fear that keeps him powerful. Of course he has mostly given the operational details over to psychologically damaged or defective henchpersons like Stephen Miller and Hegseth and Kristi Noem, but the original impulses are Trump’s own. And they do indeed include murder–if not on Fifth Avenue, then ever closer to it.
“President Trump announced on Friday afternoon that he would grant “a Full and Complete Pardon” to a former president of Honduras, Juan Orlando Hernández, who, as the center of a sweeping drug case, was found guilty by an American jury last year of conspiring to import cocaine into the United States…The judge in his case, P. Kevin Castel, had called Mr. Hernández “a two-faced politician hungry for power” who masqueraded as an antidrug crusader while partnering with traffickers. And prosecutors had asked the judge to make sure Mr. Hernández would die behind bars, citing his abuse of power, connections to violent traffickers and “the unfathomable destruction” caused by cocaine.”…” Game recognize game.
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/28/world/americas/trump-pardon-honduras-hernandez.html?unlocked_article_code=1.408.wpCl.mC_ONRjImNkr&smid=url-share
We have no proof these murdered people in boats are drug runners. Intentional? Hegseth’s survivors have the information. Bad police strategy to kill them if they are.
Unsubstantiated spitballing here. Drug lords compete for market share. Without getting information from low level rug runners about the operations, drug lords are protected. You don’t have to touch the drugs to make wealth from the drugs. Which drug lords use drug runners in these waters? Where do they launder their vast drug proceeds?
Financial criminals in the USA launder money for rich people. Does the trump/hegseth military favor any particular drug lords? Hernandez?
#te
Actually, I think Trump doesn’t really care about drugs, other than the fact he is not getting his share off the top. Maybe if the cartels were to cut him in (and pay for branding privileges) a deal could be reached.
Maybe a protection racket warning – bombs on the high seas?
An excellent analysis, but it would be irresponsible not to speculate that Hagueseth’s personal demon of compensatory hypermasculinity long predated his time in Afghanistan.
Thank you. I was thinking the same thing but forgot to mention it. That type and degree of personality deformation does not, in my experience, arise from experiences in (even early) adulthood.
This also applies to Kristi Noem, whose willingness (eagerness?) to shoot her own puppy–and goat–may have disqualified her as a VP candidate, but surely kept her in Trump’s quiver as someone with the Right Stuff for a cabinet of killers.
I just completed the Hegseth Fitness Challenge:
I posted a 2 minute video of myself doing 3 pushups and 3 pullups with wrong technique then bragging that I did 50 pullups and 100 pushups in 5 minutes.
“Hagueseth”
I see where you’re going with this, or, rather, where he;s going.
In just a HegsEk.
(a Captain Heinz Wilhelm HegsEck)
Pete Hegseth on Sept. 5 2025, at the rebranding of the DOD in the Oval Office declared our military would use, “Maximum lethality, not tepid legality; violent effect, not politically correct.” Let the War Crimes begin.
Weird that Hegseth seems to have forgotten that he is in America, that no administration lasts more than four years, and that the next administration may have excellent reasons for prosecuting him for murder. In other words, he seems to be acting as if he will always have the power he has this morning, rather than meditating on the fact that he will one day have to relinquish that power.
Whiskey Pete is ever more sure he is in his version of America. Its just that his version is a dark. inverted comic version, nothing like the sunnier myths most of us were spoon-fed as children. Gotta wonder who raised him.
“Gotta wonder who raised him”
Violent movies, and cartoons, until he was old enough to read the left-over right-wing trash he found.
They are all acting as if accountability is impossible. Either consumed by the cult or planning things
Hegseth is counting on not getting prosecuted by any court — federal or military. There certainly are risks to that approach since Trump could decide to throw him under the bus (or fast-boat) at any time if SECWAR seems to be undermining him.
Pardon me?
Excellent legal reasons, sure. Political reasons, not so much.
While I do not disagree with anything in the post or the comments, the lesson I take away is different: For 75 years, at least, the CIA has run rampant, committing monstrous (and usually stupid) crimes, and no one has ever had the political nerve to corral them.
I assume he is counting on an unconditional pardon from Trump. I’m guessing they all are.
It might seem like a little thing, but I wonder how many countries would deny entry to those pardoned by Trump, once his administration has collapsed.
2 thoughts- Rep Maria Salazar plainly said a couple of days ago, at a press conference with Steve Scalice and someone else prominent I don’t remember who, that what is happening with Venezuela is about their government letting “our oil companies” onto their land to take their oil.
Can Hegseth’s former military branch reinstate him to active duty so they can court martial him? Now, or in 3 years?
Thank you for this article and your always amazing and necessary insight.
One thing about the GOP to keep in mind: Someone is *always* saying the quiet part out loud. And in public. To the press.
The trick is getting the press to pay attention and report it.
Taking their oil = another war crime
I wonder if someone pitched this theft as possible, reasonable, and parallel to Trump’s desire to take Syria’s oil.
Another in the series titled “Taking their oil = another war crime”
“Yes, the Iraq War was a war for oil, and it was a war with winners: Big Oil.
It has been 10 years since Operation Iraqi Freedom’s bombs first landed in Baghdad. And while most of the U.S.-led coalition forces have long since gone, Western oil companies are only getting started.
Before the 2003 invasion, Iraq’s domestic oil industry was fully nationalized and closed to Western oil companies. A decade of war later, it is largely privatized and utterly dominated by foreign firms….”
https://www.cnn.com/2013/03/19/opinion/iraq-war-oil-juhasz/
Venezuela’s oil industry has been nationalized since 1976.
While Chevron or other US oil companies might benefit from regime change, the big winners could be those Cuban exiles who want to see the collapse of the island’s government. Venezuela helps provide subsidized oil to Cuba and cutting it off would have severe economic consequences. I see Little Marco lobbying Trump for this big opportunity in exchange for his obsequiousness. It was never about the dope.
Interesting.
For the most part, those exiles have to be as young in age as their mid 70s.
Would their offspring feel the same way about wanting the collapse of Cuba’s government?
TAP just published a fascinating piece about who has/could benefit from a takeover of Venezuela’s oil, and how it’s quite complex because of how the takeover of their national oil company that operates in the US has been ongoing for years already in the US courts. Really really good read, highly recommend!!
“The $30 Billion Identity Theft of Venezuela”
—–
‘How Juan Guaidó sucked a weary nation dry, and primed it for the current U.S.-led assault’
—–
by Maureen Tkacik
https://prospect.org/2025/11/26/30-billion-dollar-identity-theft-of-venezuela/
Is there a statute of limitations on murder?
No, and FWIW on an earlier query, Hegseth can be recalled for a general court martial more reasonably than Mark Kelly can. He was a MN NG officer and is probably at least on the inactive list. So, he can be tried for murder, as can every military person in the chain of command that did the deed, especially the double tap.
The Geneva Conventions provide the legal rationale, and even if one believes these were enemy combatants (I do not), they got POW status once their ability to fight back became inoperative. You can’t just shoot prisoners. As a ratified treaty, the Geneva Conventions also have Constitutional status.
As for our alleged DC shooter, I have to wonder how he got to DC from Washington state without detection by DHS with its CBP and ICE goons, or Kash Patel’s FBI. Did he drive, fly, or what? I find it hard to believe he left no paper/electronic trail that he was on the move, and since the much ballyhooed crackdown on Muslims has been going for a while (including asylum seekers) I suspect we’ve seen another example of Convict-1’s incompetence in keeping America safe. This is what happens when Noem prioritizes easy pickings over doing the job right.
I read at AP that he drove. That’s several days of travel. Clearly all those license-plate readers aren’t useful.
I’m sure the license-plate readers can read license plates.
But it looks like they can’t read human minds and intent.
They need to have their programming rewritten.
I suspect license-plate readers provide too much data (and thus the need for AI?) Of course anyone looking into it would probably discover that a lot of information about the D.C. shooter was classified.
One of the most abhorrent aspects of government by Trump is the floating of conspiracies to explain all that happens. That said, knowing the CIA is under Ratcliffe leads me to consider whether Lakanwal was sent from Washington to DC on a mission to create a false flag event. The peculiar circumstances surrounding the Butler shooting also contribute to my believe that there is zero presumption of regularity that can be afforded this regime.
If, and that is a gargantuan if, this was the case, these morons will not be able to keep it secret for long.
I, for one, do not think this and prefer not to dive into the rabbit hole of CT as it is counter productive.
The truth will out eventually.
Recently had dinner with an attending from the Butler hospital where Trump was taken after the shooting. They didn’t even put in a single stitch!
#tu
yes, false flags here, false flags there, false flags everywhere.
and, as i learned here at EW: in our donald’s world, every accusation is an admission; and blame the victim every time.
false flag “anti-semitism,” false flag “excellence in education,” false flag “healthcare,” false flag “peace plans,” false flag “indictments” . . . . and if it isn’t false flag operations, it is simply false/fake: boobs, eyelashes, tans, hair, assassination attempts — it’s endless.
Rugger, and even more reasonably, Adm. Frank M. “Mitch” Bradley:
That blockquote follows Marcy’s “The Special Operations commander overseeing the Sept. 2 attack” linked blockquote from the same WaPo article. Here’s a gift link:
https://wapo.st/4rqHdi7
And by the way, if “no quarter” rings a bell, search on this from Sen. Tom Cotton—an Army officer who knows no quarter means the enemy is allowed neither to retreat nor surrender:
“Adm. Frank M. “Mitch” Bradley, told people on the secure conference call that the survivors were still legitimate targets because they could theoretically call other traffickers to retrieve them and their cargo, according to two people.”
Oh, come on! Whatta bunch of crap! If that is so, it’s even more reason to interdict, seize the evidence, and arrest.
Nothing reasonable about it. Bradley sounds like an idiot.
“Hello, Juan? Say, the American military blew up the boat and then just left. I’m clinging to a seat cushion and trying to keep the bails of drugs from drifting away. Could you come and pick me up?”
Is it just me or is the idea that an Admiral could issue a kill order that relies on the word and concept “theoretically” chilling to winter’s bone?
Theoretically I (or you) could use a phone to call drug traffickers. There have to be a lot of unclaimed phones in the Caribbean. Drug traffickers have friends in high places, including the White House.
Where did Trump/Hegseth find an Admiral like this?
Rugger, if Trump pardons Hegseth, does it negate a court marshall ?
I think it would since it was done as a federal crime, not a state one because no US State has high seas authority. The Hague is another matter. FWIW, Convict-1 all the way down is subject to ICC prosecution even if the USA still doesn’t recognize it, and I don’t see Convict-1 pardoning the help.
Yup. As he continues his quest to turn himself into Vladimir Putin and America into Russia, Donald Trump may be making his future international travel (plus that of SECDEF Hegseth and SOCOM Commander ADM Frank “Mitch” Bradley) more like Putin’s…now quite limited, as he is subject to arrest in most countries countries per war crime charges from the International Criminal Court (ICC) at The Hague.
Trump’s use of military force to kill civilians without any legal justification and outside of any wartime action, is a definable crime, for which any wronged country signing The Rome Treaty of the ICC can bring criminal charges before the ICC, and any of those countries can arrest them on those ICC charges.
In the future, Trump’s Qatar Force One flights to Scotland for golf may not be possible—but instead limited, as currently are Putin’s, to Anchorage and Moscow (OK, plus China and India. Also North Korea and a few other smaller countries).
https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/situation-ukraine-icc-judges-issue-arrest-warrants-against-vladimir-vladimirovich-putin-and
A pardon would negate the crime, but Hegseth could still be prosecuted under UCMJ Article 134 for conduct unbecoming an officer. Convict-1 now claims he did not order or want the second tap, but that also raised questions about just how much he lets his secretaries run amok. The Article 134 prosecution would have to be for something other than the boat strikes if the pardon scenario comes to pass. However, with Whiskey Pete that is a target rich environment.
Trump still owns it even if he didn’t order it (which I doubt, the guy micromanages stuff like this) because he put Hegseth in this place and set up the operational dynamic.
reply to Rugger:
Trump micromanages stuff like redoing the bathroom in the Lincoln bedroom. Not military strikes, for which he believes he sets the policy (Stephen Miller does) and swans off to bulldoze the East Wing.
Google is your friend. Answer: no, not in the US.
Giggle is Not your friend. A competent search engine might be.
I’ve been using DuckDuckGo.
I use https:// noai.duckduckgo.com. Note the ‘noai’ part. It’s really important.
Troutwaxer says: November 30, 2025 at 8:31 am
You can turn it off in DDG without having to do that. It’s the gear symbol below the search bar when you do a search.
Nobody seems to spare a thought for the guys piloting the helicopters or the guys on land firing the missiles.
And now Hegseth is denying he gave the orders.
The pending Hernández pardon is so astonishingly hypocritical, it signals to me that Trump no longer feels the need even to try to justify or claim consistency in his actions. The only relevant questions are, Who’s getting paid? and How much? I read Roger Stone was advocating for the pardon.
It’s The Aristocrats.
https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2025/11/29/2356044/-Why-did-The-Felon-pardon-Hernandez-Apparently-to-serve-Thiel-Altman-and-Andreesen
The formulaic reaction of Trump, Noem, Patel, etc. to awful news is to blame Biden and to make unsubstantiated and, usually wrong, claims. In the aftermath of the DC shooting, they all blamed Biden for admitting the shooter into the country without vetting. A day later the news media notes that he was vetted multiple times and, that while, he entered under a Biden program, he was granted asylum by the Trump Administration, after being vetted once again.
The news media seems to accept this knee jerk gaslighting by Trump and allies. And so they become complicit. The Administration’s gaslighting is an important story in itself because it means that Trump and his allies are inherently untrustworthy. Just as some federal judges are now no longer willing to give the DOJ the presumption of regularity in following the law, the news media needs to assume that Trump and his allies are not telling the truth. And to make sure its articles reflect the low level of trust.
The DC shooter may or may not have targeted the National Guard soldiers. But his presence in this country is blowback from 20 years of our involvement in Afghanistan. Blowback is a natural consequence of military adventurism. Trump and his allies probably don’t care.
I suspect we’ll learn more about motives, but I also wonder whether the recent posturing by the administration and its noise machine made it clear that he was no longer a friend who put his life on the line for us, but an enemy to be hunted down. His background in Afghanistan (he was one of our contract killers there, see LGM’s article on this) meant that deportation there was a death sentence so he acted as he was taught by the US. Still wrong, but knowing the why is important for future actions to stop this from happening.
It is difficult to imagine just how screwed an Afghan refugee admitted after working with the US would feel while watching Trump cancel Temporary Protected Status for (apparently) nine countries, including Afghanistan, since taking office.
I’m not a wizard of immigration law, and wouldn’t be surprised if Rahmanullah Lakanwal wasn’t affected by TPS cancellation, but it’s easy to imagine that he expected they would come for him soon enough.
https://www.axios.com/2025/11/24/trump-immigration-temporary-protected-status-myanmar-burma-somalia
https://www.uscis.gov/newsroom/news-releases/dhs-terminating-temporary-protected-status-for-afghanistan
I have very little faith that the Trump Administration will divulge the motive if it is harmful to them to do so. It might make something up and feed it to the credulous media.
The Administration and the media have gone dark on Kirk’s shooter and the Butler assassin. If they can’t spin, they ignore.
Who thinks the trump administration had Rahmanullah Lakanwal over a barrel (and plenty others) and triggered by all this immigration crap, especially the new temporary protection status notice. The trump administration could have assigned this atrocious act through his CIA regular contact. DC was the first militarized city, 6 republican governors answered the call. Spread the fear across the nation. Guns are everywhere for the taking.
To paraphrase part of one of your statements, RitaRita: Some (most?) of the public is no longer able to give the news media the presumption of accurately reporting the facts.
It should take a lot of real work to re-establish what we had (or thought we had) back in the days of Cronkite, Edward R. Murrow.
I am not sure we should give the news media the presumption that they want to report facts contradicting the Administration.
> The richest man on earth owns X.
> The family of the second-richest man owns Paramount, which owns CBS — and could soon own Warner Bros. Discovery, which owns CNN.
> The third-richest man owns Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp.
> The fourth-richest man owns The Washington Post and Amazon MGM Studios.
> A billionaire owns Fox News, The Wall Street Journal, and the New York Post.
> Another billionaire owns LA Times
One might wonder what is going on. Why are right wing multibillionaires buying up so much of the media?
An ongoing, aggressive acquisition of ownership and control of media by extreme wealth, who, just happen to be fascist-friendly.
If you’re a multibillionaire, you might view democracy as a threat to your intention to control the narrative around events.
a reliable means of stopping negatives from affecting your objectives is by controlling a significant share of the dwindling number of media outlets.
As a media mogul, you can effectively hedge against democracy by suppressing criticism of yourself and other plutocrats and memory-holing attempts to question you or your pal’s running of things.
But, don’t quote me on this.
(with apologies to Robert Reich)
I watched a youtube of a recent trump press conference. A female reporter asked him a pointed question & first he chastised her for daring to ask him such a question then he called her a very stupid reporter and doubled down on his bullshit reasoning, reiterating very angrily every lie he had just said. She looked as if she might cry but overcame it. Her question was very good one but he trumped her. I had to wonder why they all didn’t tell him he was lying & storm out of the room. But of course he was angry & probably thrown something at them. He was really ranting. Dementia in full view.
The White House press corps has been culled of any reporters from outlets which might question him.
We do not have a free media institution in the U.S. anymore, just a bunch of frightened panderers torn between reporting and the attraction of eyeballs, in search of dollars and monetization. The country is being sold out and sold.
And yet, Trump still fears the media. Witness the new White House web page: “Misleading. Biased. Exposed. Media offender of the week”.
https://www.whitehouse.gov/mediabias/
We hear a lot about troops’ obligation to refuse to obey an illegal order. But I don’t know where in the UCMJ is the prohibition on *issuing* an illegal order. Must apply to Admiral Frank Bradley, at least?
ADM Bradley (four-star Admiral and Commander of U.S. Special Operations Command) was ordered by the SECDEF to issue an illegal order. In not refusing to obey that order, he personally committed an illegal act in violation of the UCMJ, differing only in degree from Lt. William Calley, whose defense was that he was following the orders of his commander, Capt. Ernest Medina. Calley was convicted by court-martial of the murder of 22 unarmed South Vietnamese civilians in the My Lai massacre on March 16, 1968, during the Vietnam War. (Total number killed was 300-500. Capt. Medina was acquitted of giving such an order. No one under Calley’s command were charged.)
During my military career (SMSgt, Ret. USAF), obligation to refuse illegal orders discussions were common. On common point was the greater the authority of the military member, the greater the responsibility to refuse a patently illegal order and protect those under your command from having to make that decision. My responsibility as a Senior NCO was greater than that of a Staff Sergeant or Senior Airman, and My Colonel’s responsibility was greater than mine.
Part of that is reflected in the differing oaths military enlisted and commissioned officer members take, as nicely explained by LtGen (ret) Mark Hertling (final assignment was Commanding General of U.S. Army Europe and Seventh Army):
https://www.thebulwark.com/p/what-americans-should-understand-about-the-military-disobeying-illegal-orders-two-oaths
Medina, according to Wikipedia, claimed that he never gave any orders to kill Vietnamese noncombatants.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernest_Medina
Pretty sure he only said “Kill them all”, nothing about unarmed civilians.
And he was acquitted, as there was no evidence beyond Calley’s accusation, that he gave that order.
Worth watching for insight into what happened at My Lai: https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/films/mylai/
Trump keeps railing about the millions killed in the Ukraine but he is really bloodthirsty here .
As to Ukraine, Timothy Snyder has a guest columnist, Nataliya Gumenyuk, on today’s post. Gumenyuk is a reporter who focuses on the Middle East and in Ukraine. She poses this provocative question:
In America, the land of the free and the home of the brave, we always root for the underdog, right? But what if Trump (and the billionaires) are supporting Goliath, not David?
https:// snyder.substack.com/p/what-if-trump-wants-goliath-to-win
Trump definitely prefers winners, not losers. His main gripe with Ukraine is they are not cooperating with him getting his Peace Prize so he will have to sell them down the river in order to claim he brought about peace.
And when you can’t get the Peace Prize, aim for the Pieces Prize.
my crystal ball says the deal is if VP gets ukraine then DJT gets Venezuela, no quibbles or complaining.
#te
what does #te mean? I keep seeing it recently and am unsure (and I tried to look it up online to no avail)
[Moderator’s note: it’s my note indicating that I had to edit a comment for a typo in a commenter’s email address. You may also see hashtag tu which denotes a typo in the username. I am trying to document how many times I’ve had to correct commenters’ typos which don’t appear to be sockpuppetry or efforts to change other information establishing their commenter identity. I plan on writing about post about this when I have enough data; for now, ignore it unless it appears in your comment. /~Rayne]
oh okay, that’s neat! I will look forward to the stats/analysis post in future (and thx for all the hard work you do moderating!)
None of the boats targeted by Hegseth have the range to make it to the US.
The Felon Guy seems to believe that the Caribbean is US-owned.
After all, it is the Gulf of America. He said its so.
Lakanwal apparently had acquired the skills to commit murder more surely, swiftly, and unobtrusively. He chose to sacrifice his life and others to make a statement. What is it? It is surely not whatever Donald Trump’s fools claim it is.
earl,
Bingo! A lot of questions to confront.
Yes, why kill the lowly getaway driver or delivery guy when what you want are the people that employ and profit from them?
An obvious rationale is that Trump’s gang of fools can do the first, but not the second. They can rattle sabers by attempting to “close” Venezuelan air space, an unprovoked act of aggression, and possibly bomb randomly. But would that get close to drug lords, who, to paraphrase Raymond King, measure their cash horde by weighing it in 18-wheelers.
I wonder why the Russians are apparently saber-rattling and supporting Venezuela if putin’s BFF trump is planning to attack it.
I suspect the rulers of the oligarchs, Vlad, donnie, etc. want it all for themselves. Can one consider the oligarchs constitute the financial wings of the fascists who want to own the monopoly to fossil fuel, dissing other sources.
The Trump Administration is more interested in putting on a show than achieving progress in stopping drug smuggling. It is the same with their deportation of migrants. Trump said he would prioritize and go after the violent criminals who are here illegally. Instead they put on shows of men rappelling from helicopters and go after the defenseless migrants.
One ringy dingy, two ringy dingies,…
I can’t get to your call so leave me a message at the tone. Speak slowly so my receptionist can get all the information right, especially the soft voice secret ones.
Beeeeeeeeeep.
Jeffrey, it’s Donald. Since you’re friendly with all the world’s leaders, can you take a few minutes in your busy schedule to call Maduro and tell him to surrender so I can get that Peace Prize? Thanks. And yes, keep this ask a secret. May every day be another wonderful secret.
Click.
A Victorious Secret, no less.
Defenseless people are much easier to collect. Criminals actually have a clue about their own safety.
When we train a young man to kill his own countrymen, for pay, by an invading force how the hell do we expect him to behave going forward in his life?
Trump likes to use the protection of the office of president to pretend he is the Capo di tutti capi and due his tribute. It appears the grift has filtered down throughout the GOP.
Hey, you have to respect your leaders, especially when they are showing you how to game the system, although most of his followers were already well on the path of crime.
Something else to take into consideration is how the pardon of Hernandez relates to the development of Prospera. There are interesting connections to Project 2025, to Peter Thiel, to Africa, to cryptocurrency and more in this article:
“A Libertarian Island Dream in Honduras Is Now an $11 Billion Nightmare” – 2/14/25
“Prospera touts itself as the world’s most ambitious experiment in self-governance. Critics say its founders have lost their way”
https://archive.ph/2025.02.17-035021/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2025-02-13/a-honduras-dream-city-now-faces-11-billion-political-dispute
Thanks for that Bloomberg piece on “Prospero”. At first it sounded like a good plot for modern version of “Lord of the Flies” for stupid rich people. And then I realized it’s just another way for the stupid rich people to take over land that they want.
Seriously, in such a place who would be top dog? None of these techbros have egos that are willing to let anyone else call the shots, so it might be interesting to see how they take each other out in the jungle.
Prospera sounds as silly as Thiel’s floating sovereign cities.
It’s the same idea, just not floating…
Great article Thank You. It seems only a matter of time before the US Government is on the receiving end of a multi billion dollar class action law suit for the murder of people in the Gulf of Mexico. They destroyed the evidence, and broadcast the murders simultaneously.
Not the Gulf of Mexico, but the Caribbean Sea, which is not US territory.
Another odd occurrence: a Venezuelan oil refinery exploded and burned last week: https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/world/fireball-rocks-venezuela-oil-facility-amid-tensions-with-us-trumps-plot-to-loot-says-maduro/vi-AA1QMVJd
Question: Can Trump issue pre-emptive pardons for Hegseth and anyone who participated in ‘Operation War Crime’?
Yes. Pete could be insulated from federal prosecution by a preemptive pardon from Trump…if Trump feels like it (ask Roger Stone about this) and has time out from all the other pardons he’ll be issuing.
That does not protect Hegseth from military prosecution or state law. Or civil prosecution, which I hope his victims’ families figure out a way to pursue.
If I am not mistaken, Hegseth is now denying he gave any such order. You’ve gotta be one unaware person to not say: ‘You want me to kill these people without knowing anything about them? Put it in writing, and I’ll show it to the legal people first. Just trying to save you some embarrassment, sir.’
It’s in the Guardian. He’s throwing the servicemen under the boat, so to speak.
I don’t think the admiral would have invented that order. That stuff *always* comes from higher up.
See Purple Martin November 29, 2025 at 2:57 pm and responses above re-Medina.
One great thing about Hegseth’s public denial is that all other service members now see Hegseth’s will hang them out to dry. He will deny and let the blame fall on them. They’re taking illegal orders from a coward who does not have their backs. Are they willing to lose their careers or go to jail for a coward poseur?
I wonder if Trump would pardon Elchapo for a few bucks
Seventeen (17) of El Chapo’s family members were allowed legal entrance to the US at San Ysidro, CA in May 2025.
It would be more than a few bucks, discreetly invested in Trump cybercrime tokens as a gesture of gratitude.
I wonder if Lakanwal could end with the Jeffrey Epstein version of suicide mimicking the Putin oops! out the window suicide before he gets a chance to go to trial…
“…shot (in the back) while trying to escape.”
‘The suspect hit my boot repeatedly with their face in a most aggressive manner.’
That’s about Trump’s level.
Suicide by multiple shots to the head and back…
Tied themselves at hands and feet and then hanged themselves…
Super inconvenient that his injuries were not lethal.
Major Strasser: You would find the conversation a trifle one-sided. Señor Ugarte is dead.
Captain Renault: I am making out the report now. We haven’t quite decided yet whether he committed suicide or died trying to escape.
Latest is he was having problems and the community was worried.
https://apnews.com/article/lakanwal-national-guard-shooting-suspect-afghan-5e5e9567d95a5d0ef806b714bb3ee3b7
Mentally ill after being a trained killer in combat, with easy access to deadly weapons? Who could have predicted this?
Wow! Boom! Zing! Great post! Thanks so much Dr. Wheeler for one of your most hard-hitting posts ever. You destroy a number of Trump regime talking points in one column. As usual, the links are really helpful too. Spencer Ackerman’s article, in particular, drives home the point that the recent tragic shooting of the Guardsmen in DC is the bitter harvest of 20 years of brutal warfare in Afghanistan and Iraq. Many minds were warped indelibly by that pointless conflict. There are many broken people, including the arrogant young Mr. Hegseth, who became heartless killers because of 20 years of brutality and glorification of guns and weaponry. A militaristic society is a sick society. Thank you for your insights.
“the bitter harvest of 20 years of brutal warfare in Afghanistan and Iraq”
Lessons not learned in Viet Nam or any other conflicts.
[I wasn’t sure where to post this because there are related discussions
going on both here and at the Fridays with Nicole post…why not both?]
re: Illegal Orders
Statement of the “Former JAGs Working Group” on Media Reports of
Pentagon “No Quarter” Orders in Caribbean Boat Strikes https://www.justsecurity.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/former-jag-working-group-no-quarter-statement.pdf
29 November 2025
The title of the post should read Murderer not Murder.
The liberating Armed Forces of WWII over the last eighty years has evolved into the Armed Forces of the murdering of unarmed non threatening civilians. In a just world, one day, all in the chain of command, from the commander in chief down to the personnel who pulled the trigger will be prosecuted for murder. Failing to offer aid to the wounded on the high seas after defeat is the true sign of a degenerate command structure. The renaming of the Department of Defense to the Department of War rightly should be called the Department of Murder.
Did you read the post? Because a particular act is common to the two subjects.
Every word and every comment. Thank you
We had a good discussion re: HAGUESETH on the occasion of his Senate confirmation hearing:
How Right Wingers Rushed to DEI Hire Pete Hegseth
https://www.emptywheel.net/2025/01/15/how-right-wingers-rushed-to-dei-hire-pete-hegseth/
January 15, 2025
They Confirmed Him Anyway — Digby
https://digbysblog.net/2025/11/30/they-confirmed-him-anyway/
In Confirmation Hearing Exchange with King, Defense Secretary Nominee Refuses to Rule Out Use of Torture
https://www.king.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/in-confirmation-hearing-exchange-with-king-defense-secretary-nominee-refuses-to-rule-out-use-of-torture
Hegseth is not a warrior. A warrior practices a trade which has rules and obligations that must be observed and respected. All Hegseth has is his need for ego-fulfilling enhancement.
Hegseth, like Trump, has no idea what rules are for and why they save lives and honor. The Princeton and Harvard man has no idea what “prerogatives” are. He just “knows” that whatever restrains his ego must be a bad and dastardly thing, whose only purpose could be to deflate the one thing in life that gives him meaning. Hegseth is the cartoonish alter-ego Donald Trump has been looking for.
Thousands of men and women, with deep experience of what happens on the battlefield and its peacetime consequences, have spent decades and more attempting to reach agreement about how to make victory survive what they do to achieve it.
Ouch. Earl, I winced at your reminder that Hegseth and I share an alma mater. I suspect both of us were outsiders at Princeton. As a female student trying to major in physics when “the ratio” was 5:1 overall, I was always the only woman in my physics classes. I could not have paid my instructors to help me. When my depression flared into mania my sophomore year I completely decompensated. Academic probation followed, and I hung on by the skin of my teeth.
I believe that Pete Hegseth, coming from a middle class family, likely overcompensated. He tried to prove he could compete on the Princeton playing field, and obviously he succeeded. A little failure might have done him a lot of good–not least by instilling some empathy for others who struggle.
My Princeton story ended well. A sensitive provost observed that I had excellent grades in creative writing and languages, and bargained me into changing my major at the beginning of my junior year. I was terrified of joining the then-hyper-competitive English department, not knowing the skills involved, but I graduated summa cum laude and was able to talk my way into Cornell’s doctoral program despite my sorry GPA.
Pete Hegseth was a star until he hit the military. He’s been lying about this ever since. If you take his path of faking it till you make it, you may indeed make it. But Princeton can teach you to lie in order to fit in.
Didn’t he originally “retire” because of various violations of UCMJ?
Scooting between different state National Guards can be a way of blurring (if not actually cleansing) your record.
It’s telling that in his Quantico pep rally for the senior flag and general officers (and most senior enlisteds), Hegseth tried to reinforce his points by telling them what he wanted to see as a platoon leader. Does he have any idea of the distance between platoon leaders and those people who wear stars and have the term “Commander” after their name?
Hegseth is the living and (mouth-) breathing exemplar of the Peter Principle.
Wow, wow, wee, “the suspect in the National Guard shooting was radicalized in the U.S.”
WASHINGTON — Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said on NBC News’ “Meet the Press” Sunday that authorities believe the suspect in the National Guard shooting was radicalized in the U.S. and that the asylum process for migrants would resume once the administration has dealt with a backlog of applications under new standards following the attack.
Her comments come after Trump said he would “permanently pause” migration from “third world countries” after the suspect in the National Guard shooting was identified as an Afghan national. NBC News previously reported that the suspect was granted asylum this year.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/noem-says-national-guard-shooting-140212247.html
Given what the US government has been in The Felon Guy’s administrations, I’m surprised more people haven’t become obviously “radicalized”.
I don’t believe a word out of that liar’s mouth.
While the putative Ukraine surrender talks continue in Fla, one crucial factor that implies a (blame-adjusted, natch) Russian default is that Putin daren’t allow his own deeply-traumatised troops to quit. Russia’s wartime turkeys coming home to roost would be several orders of magnitude worse than Trumpamerica’s with its relatively small number of immigrant vets.
They’re having problems with those turkeys coming home. Some of the convicts released to serve at the front are gong home and criming. Or criming at/near the front.
James Li from Youtube reports google search spikes of the National Guard shooter prior to the time of the shootings. These search results have since been scrubbed. Watch the link below.
https://youtube.com/shorts/Mzdej1dkrQ0
[Moderator’s note: YouTube link edited to remove tracking. Please also use the SAME USERNAME and email address each time you comment so that community members get to know you. You attempted to publish this comment as “applesauce” triggering auto-moderation; it has been edited to reflect your established username. Letter case and spelling matter. Please check your browser’s cache and autofill; future comments may not publish if username does not match. /~Rayne]
I don’t have the link, but I saw a similar youtube video a while after Charlie Kirk’s death.
It stated that there where multiple searches originating in either DC and, or, Israel. These pre-incident search spikes included Tyler Robinson, the specific building that he allegedly shot from, the hospital he was taken to, and I think the Utah Medical Examiner.
I have no way of knowing if any of the search spikes really happened. It is out of my league to track down possibly scrubbed google data.
I’m watching Laura Coates on CNN right now – a rarity for me – and she has f***ing JOHN YOO on, talking about the strikes on the alleged drug boats. EvenJohn Yoo is saying this is not legitimate, that what happened is likely a war crime. I’d say Hegseth and all who followed him down this path are in deep guano. Deservedly so.