The Government Still Doesn’t Say Whether or Not It Has Recordings of James Risen

There’s an interesting passage in this government filing to get Judge Leonie Brinkema to reconsider her guidelines regarding James Risen’s testimony in the Jeffrey Sterling suit. It seems to address Brinkema’s suggestion in her ruling that there might be recordings of Sterling passing classified information to Risen.

The government has not stated whether it has nontestimonial direct evidence, such as email messages or recordings of telephone calls in which Sterling discloses classified information to Risen; nor has it proffered in this proceeding the circumstantial evidence it has developed.

Here’s how the government responds.

There is no non-testimonial direct evidence in this case that can establish what Risen can. There are no recorded telephone calls in which Sterling discloses classified information to Risen, nor are there emails in which Sterling discloses the same. Had there been such recordings or emails, that evidence would have been disclosed in the Bruce Declaration5 or in the government’s response to Risen’s motion to quash the 2010 grand jury subpoena, and the government certainly would have provided such discovery after indictment. There simply is no such evidence.

5 The Bruce Declaration, which the Court has had in an unredacted, classified form since 2008, and which the government adopted and re-submitted in 2010, is an accurate and fair summary of the anticipated trial evidence in this case. See Dkt. 144. The defendant received a redacted, classified version of the Bruce Declaration on June 18, 2011. Pursuant to this Court’s Order of June 28, 2011, the government provided counsel for Risen a redacted, unclassified version of the Bruce Declaration (that remains under seal) on June 29, 2011, so that counsel for Risen would have an adequate factual background for the hearing on July 7, 2011.

Note they don’t say they don’t have any recorded telephone calls between Risen and Sterling. Rather they say, “There are no recorded telephone calls in which Sterling discloses classified information to Risen, nor are there emails in which Sterling discloses the same.” They attribute that claim to their Bruce Declaration, which as they note provides a list of all the evidence they intend to use, not all the evidence they have.

That’s important, because we know they have the content of emails, at least those from Sterling to Risen. The indictment references a March 10, 2003 email from Sterling to Risen suggesting that Risen read an article on Iran.

Defendant STERLING stated, “I’m sure you’ve already seen this, quite interesting, don’t you think? All the more reason to wonder … J.”

The indictment also accuses Sterling of “meeting with Author A in person to orally disclose classified information.

The only two ways I can think of to know that is if, 1) they knew Sterling didn’t pass information via their phone calls because they have all those calls, or 2) if he if specifically referenced meeting to give him information in an email. But the government has introduced no evidence of the latter, at least not publicly.

I suspect Brinkema has good reason to suspect the government has wiretaps of Sterling talking to Risen (if they did, given the circumstances of the case, there’d be a good chance they got those wiretaps from their vacuuming of information at circuits, not from a formal wiretap placed on Sterling’s phone). And now, along with the dance over how much Brinkema will permit the government to ask Risen on the stand, they’re conducting a dance over whether or not the government will have to admit that.

8 replies
  1. GulfCoastPirate says:

    EW – Sorry to go off topic but I just wanted to send good wishes to all my friends on the East Coast this weekend. This storm looks a lot like Ike that hit us in 2008 in that it’s having trouble keeping an eyewall but it covers such a large surface area that it’s going to be pushing a lot of water in front of it. I’m not sure of all the topography on the East Coast but if you’re in a low lying area be careful. That wall of water is going to be pushing a lot of debris and as it moves inland it’s going to pick up even more debris from the coastline. Remember, hide from the rain – run from the water.

    GCP’s Do’s and Don’t In Hurricanes

    1. Don’t drink a lot of alcohol after it goes through. It’s going to be hot after and with all the water around very humid. Alcohol will suck it out of you. Drink as much water as you can find to fight the humidity.

    2. If you lose power and have some neighbors around try to coordinate eating with them. Food will stay frozen in your freezer for 2 or 3 days so there’s no use in everyone breaking out the bar-b-q pit right after the storm and cooking everything then. Too much goes to waste and you don’t know when you’ll get power back. Or even when ice may be available. Stagger the cooking and have everyone eat together so the food lasts longer or it’s beans out of a can for everyone after the first day.

    3. Buy lots and lots of charcoal. Even if you have a gas stove. With no power and no air conditioning it’s too hot to cook in the house. Get some aluminum foil also. Grilled peaches, pineapple, etc out of the can placed on a piece of foil on the grill isn’t a bad dessert.

    4. Get some tortillas. They keep longer than bread, are filling and you can wrap them around anything. Easy to heat up on the grill.

    5. Lots and lots and lots of water. If you get a pretty bad hit there is going to be a lot of cleanup with all that water pushing all that debris so stay hydrated.

    6. When the power comes back on get shitfaced. You’ve earned it. I prefer a nice chianti with periodic tequila shots but this is a personal decision. :)

    Stay safe everyone.

  2. orionATL says:

    misleading the court through lawyerly lying.

    yet again.

    when is the federal judiciary as a whole going to start haulin really hard on the reins of the doj’s runaway prosecutors.

  3. Gitcheegumee says:


    Greta tips. Here’s another,if you have a hot tub,fill it with water,as the water lines may be inoperative,and this reserve water can be used for flusing the toilets,among other non potable purposes.

    Also,if you have to evacuate, the dishwasher is a very handy repository for many items,besides dishes,to provide a degree of protection.

  4. Bob Schacht says:

    “Also,if you have to evacuate, the dishwasher is a very handy repository for many items,besides dishes,to provide a degree of protection.”

    I once knew a lady who kept all her jewelry in her dishwasher.

    Bob in AZ

Comments are closed.