Al-Haramain Will Not Appeal 9th Circuit Decision Immunizing Illegal Wiretapping

The single best chance to hold the government accountable for its illegal wiretapping, the al-Haramain suit, is over.

Our goal was for the judiciary to rule that the president may not disregard an act of Congress in the name of national security.


Ironically, although we had sought a judicial pronouncement that the president may not violate FISA, the 9th Circuit instead proclaimed that he can get away with it.


We have decided not to challenge the 9th Circuit’s ruling in the U.S. Supreme Court. We feel that, given the Supreme Court’s current ideological tilt, it is better to leave other courts free to disagree with the 9th Circuit than to risk a bad ruling by the current Supreme Court.

The Al-Haramain case is over. Perhaps someday another court will adjudicate the scope of the president’s domestic wiretapping powers in a national climate less charged by post-9/11 fears.

With these words, Jon Eisenberg, the lawyer representing al-Haramain in its suit against the government for violating FISA, publicly described his decision not to appeal the 9th Circuit’s finding that the government is immune from penalties for violating FISA.

The resolution of the al-Haramain case has been little noted in the halls of DC. But it really underlies the entire debate about the FISA Amendments Act extension.

Because as shitty as the law just renewed is, the government also now knows that they don’t even have to follow that law. They are effectively immune from the law.

Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Reddit0Share on Facebook0Google+0Email to someone

7 Responses to Al-Haramain Will Not Appeal 9th Circuit Decision Immunizing Illegal Wiretapping

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
Emptywheel Twitterverse
JimWhiteGNV RT @CIAspygirl: Congrats @JonathanLanday on the new gig! Looking forward to your stories for @Reuters. via @HuffPos
JimWhiteGNV RT @TheTweetOfGod: No he won't. If anything he'll ask them for help with the catering.
JimWhiteGNV I love having @ChrisArcher42 on my TV in the playoffs. But it would be much better if he were pitching. #Rays
JimWhiteGNV RT @JT__Orlando: GO ASTROS
JimWhiteGNV @ArifCRafiq On the positive side, it was so slow that I sneaked in a quick nap.
JimWhiteGNV I despise the #Yankees and would be thrilled for them to be the first team eliminated in the playoffs.
JimWhiteGNV So Fred Hiatt wants his guns all antiseptic and across the ocean from where he might get caught in the crossfire.
JimWhiteGNV How bad is the gun situation in the US? So bad that Mr. "I Never Met A War I Didn't Like" Fred Hiatt is for banning:
emptywheel @laRosalind DOES Sony pay taxes? Don't they instead persist by sucking off tax bonuses?
emptywheel @saraschaefer1 Tell them that according to the NSA, it doesn't count as received until you open it. @dansinker
emptywheel @ncardozo And also to govt as a session identifier AKA CDR under USAF. But that's secret. Gonna take another @snowden to learn that.
emptywheel If corporations need this kind of hand-holding for cyber™ can we increase their taxes?
January 2013
« Dec   Feb »