Harry Pregerson

“Liberal” 9th Circuit Deals Death Blow To Al-Haramain Illegal Wiretapping Accountability Case

There is only one substantive case left in litigation with the ability to bring tangible accountability for the illegal and unconstitutional acts of the Bush/Cheney Administration’s warrantless wiretapping and surveillance program. That case is Al-Haramain v. Bush/Obama. Yes, there is still Clapper v. Amnesty International, but that is a prospective case of a different nature, and was never designed to attack the substantive crimes of the previous Administration.

A little over a couple of hours ago, late morning here in the 9th, the vaunted “most liberal of all Circuit Courts of Appeal”, the Ninth Circuit, drove what may be the final stake in the heart of Al-Haramain by declining to conduct an en banc review of its August 7, 2012 opinion. The notice from the court today is brief:

The opinion filed on August 7, 2012, and appearing at 690 F.3d 1089, is hereby amended. An amended opinion is filed concurrently with this order.

With these amendments, the panel has voted to deny the petition for panel rehearing and the petition for rehearing en banc.

The full court has been advised of the petition for rehearing and rehearing en banc and no judge has requested a vote on whether to rehear the matter en banc. Fed. R. App. P. 35.

The petition for panel rehearing and petition for rehearing en banc are DENIED. No further petitions for en banc or panel rehearing shall be permitted.

Before going further with analysis, a word about the “amendments” to the opinion. The “Amended Opinion” is here. You can compare for yourself to the August 7 original opinion linked above, but the difference is pretty slight.

It appears all the court did is delete a few sentences here and there about 18 USC 2712(b). The court did not address, nor change, their erroneous assertion that plaintiffs’ Al-Haramain could have sued under 1806(a), or restore the misleadingly-omitted (by elipsis) language from 1806(a). Nor did the Continue reading

Emptywheel Twitterverse
bmaz @WojYahooNBA @JWGOP Was hoping he would come to the Suns, but great pickup for Pop and the Spurs
bmaz @theurbansherpa Happy trails to you and yours this fine Fourth!
bmaz @Johngcole Yeah, wouldn't bother me, basically don't use it at all, too much BS and clutter there.
bmaz Don't know much about Ellen Pao, but between Kleiner Perkins and now Reddit, she sure is racking up quite a record of shitstorms.
bmaz @BloggersRUs Perfect!
bmaz @theurbansherpa Take water when you hike!
bmaz @DanCBarr Thanks, that is really good.
bmaz RT @DanCBarr: Barbara Kingsolver on the Confederate flag. The best thing you'll read on the subject. http://t.co/SPJWwiuWpD
bmaz A hilarious Monty Python sketch explains why Greece is in a huge crisis http://t.co/u7EscvVxiy
bmaz RT @Millicentsomer: Bull Shipping: On Chilean Mothers and California Gold. <--my bit. So psyched to be part of this great issue of @VQR. ht…
bmaz RT @davidminpdx: No constitutional power is as broad, unfettered as clemency, and yet Washington DC has put up tons of fake roadblocks http…
July 2015
« Jun