US Endangers Public Health Efforts with Spying, Again

Jim and I have both written a bunch about the dangers of using public health campaigns as cover for spying, as CIA did when it asked Dr. Shakeel Afridi to try to collect DNA from those on Osama bin Laden’s compound under cover of a hepatitis vaccination campaign. If those hostile to US interests suspect such campaigns — and even more pointedly, Polio vaccination campaigns — it can taint important efforts.

Today we learn that Afridi’s not the only case where US spooks have done this. As part of a campaign to have Latin American youths encourage oppositional culture in Cuba, USAID contractor Creative Associates had one contractor use an HIV prevention workshop as cover.

In one case, the workers formed an HIV-prevention workshop that memos called “the perfect excuse” for the program’s political goals — a gambit that could undermine America’s efforts to improve health globally.


“USAID and the Obama administration are committed to supporting the Cuban people’s desire to freely determine their own future,” the agency said in response to written questions from the AP. “USAID works with independent youth groups in Cuba on community service projects, public health, the arts and other opportunities to engage publicly, consistent with democracy programs worldwide.”

In a statement late Sunday, USAID said the HIV workshop had a dual purpose: It “enabled support for Cuban civil society while providing a secondary benefit of addressing the desire Cubans expressed for information and training about HIV prevention.”

Page 3 of the included documents show the subcontractor describing the HIV training as the perfect excuse, as that was something authorities would permit.

I repeat what I said earlier: Cuba would open up far more quickly if the US ended its embargoes on Cuba, especially its ban on flights to Cuba.

But instead we have to scheme short-sighted plans to open up Cuba clandestinely.

Update: Here’s a more complete description of the HIV training from the extended story.

If the idea was to hold a series of seminars to recruit new “volunteers,” Murillo needed a theme that would both draw in potential recruits and still be sanctioned by the state.

An HIV-prevention workshop was just the thing.

Months later, in November 2010, the workshop drew 60 people. Pozo also participated — evidence, Murillo said, that his scheme was working.

The workshop was supposed to offer straightforward sex education for HIV prevention, such as the proper way to use a condom.

“Cubans expressed a desire for information and training about HIV prevention, and the workshop helped to address their needs,” USAID said in response to written questions.

But the ulterior motive, documents show, was to use the workshop as a recruiting ground for young people by showing them how to organize themselves.


Reached in San Jose, Costa Rica, Murillo said he could not speak about the details of his Cuba trips because he had signed a nondisclosure agreement. He said he wasn’t trying to do anything beyond teach people how to use condoms properly.

“I never said to a Cuban that he had to do something against the government. If that was the mission of others, I don’t know,” Murillo said. “I never told a Cuban what he had to do.”

Nevertheless, Murillo’s six-page report back to Creative Associates mentioned HIV only once, to note that it was “the perfect excuse for the treatment of the underlying theme.” Elsewhere, the report revealed another objective: “to generate a network of volunteers for social transformation.”

Update: Jim (who’s prepping his daughter to go off to be-a-lawyer school) reminds me of how USAID fluffs the numbers on its health-related programs to make them look like successes.

6 replies
  1. der says:

    “instead we have to scheme short-sighted plans to open up Cuba clandestinely” Of course you’re right, it makes sense, except we have idiots who watch too many Jack Bauer and Jack Ryan thrillers in charge. Also too, Remember The (Maine) Bay of Pigs massacre by those pussy CommieSocialistTerrorists appeased by Liberal Democrats who blame America for torture, christ. Al Gore is fat and he poisoned Toledo, shoot me.

  2. ArizonaBumblebeeper says:

    I am beginning to think there is not a single aspect of American society that has not been infected by the national security state. Over recent years I have watched as various foreign governments expelled NGOs and US agencies from their countries. I always assumed that this was a paranoid reaction by their undemocratic leaders to American and European goodwill. Now, I’m not so sure of that. It is increasingly obvious to me that USAID is operating as a CIA front organization. This is a tragedy for all concerned since it taints any good work that they perform. Just a few months ago I read that the efforts to eradicate polio in Pakistan/Afghanistan have been derailed by America’s willingness to subordinate its public health objectives in those countries to national security interests. The story outlined here is consistent with what happened in that instance. As a gay man, I am outraged that the USAID would use a program to educate gay men on safe-sex practices as a vehicle to undermine a foreign government – in this case the government of Cuba. Am I the only person who finds it disgusting that America is currently sanctioning Russia for its interference in the internal affairs of Ukraine while our government blithely engages in similar practices around the world and thinks nothing of it.

  3. RUKidding says:

    Sadly, nearly all, if not 100%, of any kind of “foreign aid” that Team USA provides worldwide has been and will continue to be tainted. This is but one of many heinous examples too numerous to elaborate. I guess it only ends when Team USA is kicked out of everywhere forever & ever, which may happen sooner rather than later. How this movie ends is still somewhat up for grabs, but my bet is that ain’t going to be pretty.

    BTW, Russia mainly only “interfered” with Ukraine AFTER US taxpayers paid a cool $5billion & change to hire Nazi’s (yeah: the real-deal kind) to overthrow the lawfully elected govt of Ukraine. That said lawfully elected govt was run by a sleazebag is quite factual; but lawfully elected, nonetheless. OUR tax dollar$ then were shelled out to paint a portrait of evil evil Vlad Putin as “But HE started it,” which ain’t exactly factual.

    • bsbafflesbrains says:

      Turns out “our” Government is run by a sleazebag as well. Good news is our fearful leader only tortures some “folks”.

  4. greengiant says:

    USAID == CIA or worse, I mean even Putin can’t be wrong all the time when he kicked USAID out of Russia.

Comments are closed.