Peter Debbins Claims He Stopped Spying for Russia in 2011
The government has submitted its sentencing memorandum for Peter Debbins, the former Special Forces guy who pled guilty to spying for Russia’s GRU last November. They are asking for 17 years, arguing that gives him a slightly favorable sentence because he admitted to the spying, but one in line with other recent sentences for people who spied for foreign countries.
The memorandum provides more specifics about where Debbins was assigned and deployed when, how many of his colleagues he IDed to GRU as potential recruiting targets, and what was the security violation that got his clearance suspended in 2005 (he moved his wife to Azerbaijan and gave her a US government phone). It describes how, in spite of that past violation, he was still granted at TS/SCI clearance in 2010, shortly before (according to Debbins’ admissions) he stopped spying.
In January 2010, the U.S. Army notified Debbins via letter that he had been granted a TS/SCI security clearance. Id. ¶ 54. The letter, however, noted concerns about his business connections and father-in-law, and his prior relief of command in Azerbaijan. Id. It cautioned that a foreign intelligence service could exploit such situations and emphasized his “responsibilities for reporting any possible contact by representatives or citizens of foreign countries.”
An appendix includes a picture they found of Debbins wearing a Russian military uniform in 1994.
DOJ notes that Debbins claims he quit spying in 2011.
Debbins has claimed that his conspiracy with the Russian intelligence agents did not continue past January 2011.
But it’s clear they don’t believe him.
For example, they describe how one GRU officer used his business activities as cover for spying and then lay out how Debbins was discussing “business” with that person in 2010, shortly before he claims to have quit spying for Russia.
During this time, Debbins knew that RIS 7 used business affiliations as a cover for Russian intelligence activities. In either the 2008 or 2010 meetings, “RIS 7 provided [Debbins] with the name of his cover company and gave [Debbins] his contact information.” Id. ¶ 46. “RIS 7 instructed [Debbins] to tell his family that he was working with the cover company to explain any calls that he might have with the Russian intelligence service.” Id.
After Debbins returned to the United States from Russia in September 2010, he began exchanging a series of emails with the Russian National. See id. ¶ 60. Many of the emails referenced, at least on their face, the infrastructure project or other business projects.4 See id.
Through these emails, Debbins kept the Russian National apprised of his efforts to move from Minnesota to the Washington, D.C. area. In early November 2010, the Russian National emailed Debbins and stated that he had not heard from him in a long time. See id. ¶ 61. The Russian National specifically noted that “Ivan”—the first name of RIS 7—sent his greetings, see id., an apparent effort to prompt a response from Debbins. Sure enough, Debbins responded to the Russian National three days later, noting that he was about to move to “the capital.” See id. ¶ 62. Then, on January 3, 2011, Debbins emailed the Russian National, informing him that he had moved to “the capital” and that he was working on their business matter. See id. ¶ 63.
The sentencing memo describes how Debbins moved to DC without a job, and only then — in the wake of these conversations about “business” with a known GRU officer — applied to (but didn’t get) a bunch of agency positions, before he settled for military intelligence.
During this time, Debbins moved from Minnesota to Northern Virginia and began applying for positions in the U.S. intelligence community. He moved first to Virginia Beach in December 2010 and then to Manassas in January 2011. See Ex. A, ¶ 34. On or about December 17, 2010, Debbins applied for four positions at the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). See id. ¶¶ 9-10(a). The following month, Debbins applied for seventeen positions at the National Security Agency. See id. ¶ 11. Debbins did not obtain any of these positions. See id. ¶ 10-11.
Debbins ultimately secured a position with an intelligence branch of the U.S. Army
Throughout this period from 2011 to 2019, Debbins also applied unsuccessfully for numerous other positions in the U.S. intelligence community. As detailed in the attached declaration, he unsuccessfully applied for positions at the CIA and DIA. See Ex. A, ¶¶ 10, 12. In 2015, he applied to be a Special Agent at the FBI but later withdrew his name from consideration. See id. ¶ 13. After the 2016 presidential election, Debbins even applied to the White House, seeking to obtain a position on the National Security Council. See id. ¶ 14.
The sentencing memo doesn’t say it — but WaPo has reported that he had ties to both Mike Flynn and Erik Prince, who were being cultivated by Russia at the time he applied for the NSC job, and in the job he would have played a key Russian policy role in the Administration that Russia helped get elected.
Debbins was a graduate of and teacher at the D.C.-based Institute of World Politics, a small but influential school in conservative foreign policy circles. Former Trump national security adviser Michael Flynn and military contractor Erik Prince both have ties to the school.
In early 2017, according to emails reviewed by The Washington Post, Debbins told a friend that he was a candidate for a position on the National Security Council, “specifically Special Assistant to the President and Senior Director for Russia and Central Asia.”
The sentencing memo even describes how, for the entire time Debbins claims to have quit, he was still a security risk because of his past spying.
To make matters worse, Debbins lied about and concealed his contacts with the Russian intelligence agents for nearly a quarter of a century, even after the alleged conspiracy. By deliberately concealing the contacts during background investigations (when he had a legal obligation to report them), Debbins was able to obtain employment in sensitive positions in the U.S. intelligence community, with access to highly classified information, from April 2011 until July 2019. Debbins, a serious security vulnerability considering his history of espionage activity, put national security further at risk by lying and deceiving his way into those positions. Debbins did not reveal his contacts with the Russian intelligence agents to law enforcement until after he failed a polygraph as part of a security clearance reinvestigation in early July 2019.
A person does not harbor (as the sentencing memo describes) an ideological affinity for Russia and only quit spying once he restores his TS/SCI clearance.
And if the government, at any time over the next seventeen years (or however long his sentence) finds evidence to prove that he kept spying, then the boilerplate in his plea deal will mean they only need to prove by a preponderance of evidence that he was lying when he claimed to have quit spying to declare the deal void and sentence him to life in prison. And if that happened, that would make it easy to prosecute him for sharing what presumably would have been Top Secret information without having to risk that Top Secret information at trial.
Peter Debbins claims he quit spying in 2011. But if DOJ ever obtains proof he did not, then his lenient seventeen year sentence would very quickly become a life sentence.
I’m shocked he made it as far as he did. I hope both his mother and wife, are being watched by intelligence.
The logical conclusion then is that given the voluminous detail in the memos and the indictment is that he got caught in 2011 and was turned double agent. At least that’s what it would seem. Question is, if true, did the GRU know this too?
Nah. It’s not. At all.
If that were the case, he would not have been prosecuted, and his name wouldn’t be in the news.
Who restored Peter Rafael Dzibinski Debbins’ TS/SCI clearance despite his obvious ties to GRU? Is it possible to track down that information?
Yes, of course. The Army keeps all kinds of records. Much of the case built against Debbins involved going back through all of that. The fact that he did not disclose his Russian contacts on a SF-86 a dozen years ago, for example, is mentioned in the statement of facts. But I think it’s unlikely that anyone will be penalized for the clearance.
With the security clearance interviews I have been involved with, documentation included spouse background information and parent background information. In one instance, I had met the applicants parents and spouse’s parents a few times. The reference interview dedicated 3 hours to my knowledge about the applicants parents and in-laws.
Debbins F-I-L was an officer in the Russian military. I cannot believe that was missed.
At least one of my father’s involved his siblings (and presumably their spouses) as well. (He had to call home to check the birthdates of his siblings.)
Seems quite possible that the numerous CIA applications alone would have raised a flag of suspicion and prompted the Defense hiring under surveillance to watch over him if not actually turn him into a double.
The old “name the nuns in the church” manoeuvre. This is at least the third case I know of in which a prospective agent is induced to do this. Although essentially harmless, it’s a psychological method for prodding the agent to get over the hump. He’s not quite a little bit pregnant at this point, but on the way to it.
I’d bet that the Russians warned him to deny that there was any activity from 2011 on. For Debbins, that could mean a much longer sentence, as Marcy explained. To the Russians, though, the chief concern would be the FBI uncovering details about how he was handled in the DC area.
I wonder whether any of those SF colleagues he’d identified had later — even after retirement — been targeted with disinformation. Say, to indoctrinate them into the 3% headspace. I’ve little doubt that the Russians haven’t had their hands in that.
looks like vlad and his old timer kgb crew have just dropped all pretense and are going the full nine yards into диктаторville and doing the full Brazil
over here, over there, one has to admit it’s just fascinating times right now