John Thune’s Flopsweat about Funding Stephen Miller’s Gulag
Amid all the warmongering last week, there was an interesting head fake in the Senate.
On Tuesday, JD Vance went to a Senate lunch (rather than the Situation Room meeting on Iran) at which he told them the deadline for passing was the August recess — starting August 4.
On Wednesday, Susie Wiles went for a very short visit to the Senate to order them to get the whole thing done by July 4.
White House chief of staff Susie Wiles is encouraging Congress to get the “big, beautiful bill” to President Donald Trump’s desk by July 4.
Wiles told GOP senators at a closed-door lunch that the Independence Day deadline still holds as far as Trump is concerned, according to a person granted anonymity to describe the private meeting.
I started to write a long post (piggybacking on this one) about how the various timelines — the legal responses to Trump’s abuses and the economic impact of his disastrous policy choices — might make it harder to codify key parts of his abuses in law with the Big Ugly reconciliation bill. I was going to lay out how recent developments (this was so long ago I surmised that Trump’s Iran warmongering might cause him some political headaches and now … here we are, Trump talking regime change in the wake of an inconclusive illegal strike) might exacerbate the way his legislative agenda might be Overtaken By Events.
That post got Overtaken By Events.
The punch line of my original post was going to be an argument that Wiles was pushing the Senate to hurry up not because impending financial doom might make passing the Big Ugly harder, nor because the debt ceiling is approaching.
Rather, Kristi Noem is burning through cash.
President Trump’s immigration crackdown is burning through cash so quickly that the agency charged with arresting, detaining and removing unauthorized immigrants could run out of money next month.
Why it matters: Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is already $1 billionover budget by one estimate, with more than three months left in the fiscal year. That’s alarmed lawmakers in both parties — and raised the possibility of Trump clawing funds from agencies to feed ICE.
- Lawmakers say ICE’s parent agency, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), is at risk of violating U.S. law if it continues to spend at its current pace.
- That’s added urgency to calls for Congress to pass Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill,” which could direct an extra $75 billion or so to ICE over the next five years.
- It’s also led some lawmakers to accuse DHS and ICE of wasting money. “Trump’s DHS is spending like drunken sailors,” said Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), the top Democrat on the DHS appropriations subcommittee.
Zoom in: ICE’s funding crisis is being fueled by Trump’s team demanding that agents arrest 3,000 immigrants a day — an unprecedented pace ICE is still trying to reach.
This creates the possibility for a slew of legal challenges to Stephen Miller’s dragnet, both from those targeted in it challenging the legality of spending money to target them in the first place, but also from opponents who can start suing Trump for breaking the law by spending money that was not appropriated.
The dragnet is at somewhat-imminent risk of becoming an illegal use of funds.
And that comes as a few Republicans — most loudly, Rand Paul, who was bypassed as Chair for the Senate language on homeland security funding — start raising questions about why we need to blow so much money if Miller has already shut down the border.
Sen. Rand Paul is a frequent thorn in GOP leadership’s side. But his recent break over border security funding in President Donald Trump’s “big beautiful bill” has top Republicans pushing the bounds of institutional norms to rein him in.
Senior Republicans have sidelined the Kentucky Republican, who chairs the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, in their talks with the White House over policies under the panel’s purview.
Budget Chair Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) told POLITICO he has taken over as the lead negotiator around how to shepherd through tens of billions of dollars for border wall construction and related infrastructure in the GOP megabill. Meanwhile, a Senate Republican aide said Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.) — who heads the relevant Homeland Security subcommittee — will be the point person for negotiating the bill’s government affairs provisions.
With every other committee chair helping manage negotiations for their panels’ portions of the massive tax and spending package, cutting Paul out is unprecedented. But Paul proposed funding border security at a fraction of what the administration requested and the House passed in its bill.
I’ve long been tracking conflict among Republicans over the financial parts of the Big Ugly. But even as Trump’s polling turns south on Miller’s gulag, the huge funding package for it is creating some headaches for the must-pass reconciliation bill.
In an op-ed in Fox News today (accompanied by live Fox News pressure), John Thune gives up the game.
He argues that Republicans have to get the bill done by July 4 — Susie Wiles’ deadline, not JD’s. And his argument focuses primarily on the immigration funding (but also Golden Dome, which Mark Kelly recently exposed as an impossible boondoggle).
In large part, this bill is the culmination of President Trump’s campaign promises and the promises that Republican senators have made to our voters. Chief among them is keeping the American people safe through strong border security and a military strong enough to deter threats and conflicts around the world before they begin.
President Trump has achieved remarkable success in ending the Biden border crisis and removing the criminal illegal aliens that President Biden let walk into our country – but it hasn’t been cheap, and the administration has told us that resources are running out. This bill will fully fund the border wall and President Trump’s successful policies for the entirety of his presidency, removing any possibility that Democrats will hold those resources hostage to try to increase other government spending.
This same principle also applies to defense funding. Recent conflicts around the world should make clear the need to have a modern and lethal fighting force that can keep the American people safe. This means smart, generational investments like President Trump’s Golden Dome for America to defend against advanced drones, missiles, and hypersonics, as well as prioritizing building new ships and unmanned vehicles.
A nation cannot prosper unless it is secure, and with our borders and defense capabilities bolstered, the next key pillar of this bill is creating prosperity in America.
[snip]
Senators have worked to develop this bill for well over a year now. Now it is time to act. Border resources are drying up. National security needs have never been more apparent. And with each passing day, we move closer to reaching both our nation’s debt limit and the largest-ever tax increase on the American people.
Senators return to Washington today and we will remain here until this bill is passed. We know that Democrats will fearmonger and misrepresent our efforts, and we expect them to drag this debate long into the night with unrelated issues. However, I am confident we will get this bill across the finish line. [my emphasis]
It may not be just the burn rate of Noem’s spending spree.
That is, Noem is blowing through cash and the result of it is horrible images of American citizens being assaulted by masked goons. Noem is blowing through cash and businessmen in all sorts of industries are discovering that their businesses will suffer. Noem is blowing through cash and everyone is talking about how terrible the consequences of Miller’s demand for 3,000 bodies a day is.
Noem is blowing through cash and the issue of immigration is becoming a liability, not Trump’s biggest advantage.
And so Thune will attempt to do Susie Wiles’ bidding to get the dragnet funded before it’s too late.
It was high spending on detention that led Nazi Germany to their Final Solution.
Stephen Miller has a plan, I’m sure.
Too simplistic, unless you left off the snark tag (/d).
Martin Gilbert (Holocaust) and David Cesarini (Final Solution) offer good one volume surveys, and Christopher Browning (Origins of the Final Solution) focusses on the emergence of the actual policy and associated mechanisms between 1939-42.
Just as for Miller, the policy was baked into the ideology.
Do the federal costs of calling up the CA National Guard and deploying the Marines to LA fall under the DOD, or are they DHS expenses as their work is tied to supporting DHS/ICE/HSI?
I’d follow the chain of command but I’d bet this is under DoD, not DHS. It’s easier to bury the bones.
I also wonder what Thune will do about the parliamentarian ruling that many government affairs (AKA DOGE engineering) parts of the BUB because the reconciliation process being used for ramming this through also is subject to the Byrd Rule for allowed topics.
I fully expect Convict-1 / Krasnov / TACO and his minions will play the exigent circumstances cards (after all, DHS needs money to counteract Iranian reprisals) to wear down enough GOP critics as well as provide a sovereign immunity defense for litigation. They can only lose three (plus one for Fetterman) since I fully expect VP Vance will break any tie.
If I understood the very competent acting Comptroller (seems to be a former Mike Rogers-AL staffer) the money — $142M –comes from DOD discretionary funds.
Even for a cold-blooded swamp creature like Thune, articles like this might give pause:
ICE detains Marine Corps veteran’s wife who was still breastfeeding their baby [AP]
https://apnews.com/article/ice-detains-marine-veteran-wife-clouatre-802305fe0a364ef86a7cb61805129ee1
” … Even as Marine Corps recruiters promote enlistment as protection for families lacking legal status, directives for strict immigrant enforcement have cast away practices of deference previously afforded to military families, immigration law experts say. The federal agency tasked with helping military family members gain legal status now refers them for deportation, government memos show. …”
How’s that going to play in Pierre?
How’s that going to play in red areas where the military is the big way out of poverty?
They also beat the shit out of a guy whose three sons are Marines.
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2025-06-22/father-of-3-marines-violently-detained-federal-agents
I read that the Marine in question voted for Trump. FAFO, I guess.
But few people realize (unless you’ve breastfed) just how detrimental it is to break apart the mother/infant dyad of a breastfeeding pair. The mother’s milk constantly readjusts to perfectly match the child’s needs, the skin to skin contact improves bonding, and nursing also helps the mother’s body to repair and recover from pregnancy and childbirth. It is violence to sunder this connection.
Totally OT.
Got my four month teeth cleaning today. New tech. I am chatty – and forgiving to a point – and so learned the is from Columbia and has lived in the USA for 24 years. Did not ask if she was legal – I suspect she is, but…
She did volunteer that she voted for Trump. She also agreed that she wishes she had not along with many of her associations -family and otherwise. She inflicted no pain on my mouth.
If you wish in one hand and…you know the rest.
On the other hand it is a small victory.
Side note…my NC first cousin (female) who also voted for Trump because the black woman slept her way to the top – we have had very deep discussion on that BS – is wavering. I sent along Pope Leo’s recent “thoughts? on Trump’s BS – immigration and war – to her as she is (still) a devout Catholic. Me…not so much for a long time.
In a normal Senate, Susie Wiles’s “ordering” the Senate to do anything by July 4th would be laughed at. Even more so when she’s talking about passing the most destructive budget bill in history, on a timeline that directly contradicts a deadline suggested by the President of the Senate a short while earlier.
Dick Cheney quite possibly would have taken Wiles out behind the woodshed and she’d never reappear. I suppose things are different, when a Trinitarian Godhead rules the USG, having incorporated all three branches of govt unto Himself.
Vance has really just been on a humiliation conga line recently hasn’t he. Who would have thought that could happen to an educated but creepy Trump VP?
Vance has his eyes on the prize, he knows exactly what his job is, and he’s doing it as well as possible.
Two separate ideas. Of course, Vance wants the Presidency. Trump’s age, weight, activity and stress levels, and eating habits argue against his being in office through 2028.
That JD Vance is doing it “as well as possible” – for him – is debatable.
Does anyone other than Vance think he really has a shot at the nomination?
Is anyone other than JD Vance Vice President? He doesn’t need the nomination until 2028.
I just want to know how much she’s wasting on her damn YouTube ad where she virtue signals about thanking Trump for his immigration policy while telling the viewer to self-deport cuz she’s coming for you. I see that ad more than anything. I can only imagine it’s because she’s running for president in 2028 and wants the head start. Good luck with that. 👍
Noem’s ad plays regularly here in Chicago, especially on the late news. My wife and I have remarked that the folks this ad is targeted at aren’t watching. But Doctors, your observation that she’s doing this to advance possible 2028 ambitions is something I hadn’t considered.
[Welcome back to emptywheel. SECOND REQUEST: Please use the SAME USERNAME and email address each time you comment so that community members get to know you. I’ve changed “The Gormer Philadelphian” to “Former Philadelphian” as it is your established username. Please make a note of the username and clear your browser’s cache and autofill. /~Rayne]
Does DHS pay for her hair extensions and false eyelashes?
You mean Noem’s gender-affirming care? -__-
I’d ask the same about Trump’s gender-affirming care but I suspect he’s had some scam in place to grift the value from taxpayers without having to have a direct reimbursement.
Oh…you have not lived until you’ve stood in a TSA line (at Miami International Airport) with at least 6 big screens in view looping her talking about – to tell you the truth I tuned her out and have no freaking idea what she was talking about ad nauseam.
This happened to be a TSA line for the international J concourse so maybe it was worse than a domestic TSA checkpoint, but still.
I’m starting to hear middle-left pundits say things like “I’m not ready to call Trump our Churchill…yet” and “This needed to be done; maybe now *was* the time it had to happen.” In other words: a deja vu all over again sensation. Do they hear how much they sound like they did in 2002? Then I witnessed center-left pols (and pundits) trying to keep their records clean by steering what they conceived of as a thoughtful, centrist course–the one that got thousands of Americans and tens of thousands of Iraqis dead, without tangible benefit except to the defense contractors.
Trump’s Big Decidery Decision to bomb Iran sets up those same defense contractors ideally. Now we surely need a “Golden Dome” that costs trillions and doesn’t work the way it’s advertised to do. But maybe the toilets will flush the first time, even if no shower on God’s green earth can wash away the stench of cynical calculation and corruption behind the whole mess.
I can’t stand Rand Paul, personally, but at least he’s minimally consistent, which–with MAGA, which redefines itself situationally, on the basis of Trump’s fraying synapses–one cannot sustain. Not if you want to stay in a tribe that defines itself solely by excluding Others.
WTF would ever favorably compare Donald Trump to Winston Churchill? WSC was certainly racist and frequently illiberal. His view of the Labour Party and the benefits of imperial rule were antediluvian.
But he frequently accomplished good things. He venerated democracy and left office when he lost without trying to destroy it. He could read, write, and do more in a day than Donald Trump could do in a lifetime. Even in his dotage, he was more articulate than Donald Trump on his best day.
And he fought fascists, unlike Trump who seems to enjoy their companionship and sponsorship as part of his narcissistic supply.
I heard Marcy mention on Nicole Sander’s podcast that there is no evidence Proud Boys, Oathkeepers, and 2 Percenters are being hired by ICE. It seems to me that this is exactly the kind of thuggery they’d be only too happy to perform.
I have my doubts, and with the masks we will not know for sure.