cultural clash

Hiding Report on Fratricide in Afghanistan Doesn’t Make It Go Away

On January 20, the New York Times carried what they at first thought was a scoop on a “classified” report (pdf) on Afghan military and police personnel killing NATO forces. After they were told that the Wall Street Journal had written on the report back in June, they admitted as much in a correction. They later added another correction after I pointed out that a version of the report clearly marked “unclassified” could be found easily even though the Times referred to the report as classified. It turns out that the report had indeed been published first as unclassified but then was retroactively classified while the Wall Street Journal article was being prepared.

Events over the last few days serve to demonstrate the folly of trying to hide damaging information rather than openly reviewing it and trying to learn lessons from it. The report in question went into great detail to document the cultural misunderstandings that exist between NATO forces and their “partner” Afghan forces, and how these misunderstandings escalate to the point that Afghan personnel end up killing NATO personnel. In the executive summary of the report, we learn that “ANSF members identified numerous social, cultural and operational grievances they have with U.S. soldiers.” Arrogance on the part of U.S. soldiers often was cited, as well.

This clash of social values is at the heart of the newest wave of anti-US and anti-NATO violence in Afghanistan which erupted after an Afghan employee found Korans among materials being burned last week at a NATO base. A part of the response to the Koran burning is that on Saturday, two NATO personnel were killed inside Afghanistan’s interior ministry building. BBC reports that an Afghan police officer is suspected in the shootings:

Afghanistan’s interior ministry has said one of its own employees is suspected of the killing of two senior US Nato officers inside the ministry.

Officials earlier named police intelligence officer Abdul Saboor from Parwan province as the main suspect behind Saturday’s attack.

The NATO response to the killing was swift:

Nato withdrew all its personnel from Afghan ministries after the shooting.

The importance of this move cannot be overstated. Continue reading

Emptywheel Twitterverse
JimWhiteGNV RT @CJonesScout: Egbunu (14), Finney-Smith (13), Robinson (13).
emptywheel I wonder how many times Rahm has said "fuck" in the last 48 hours?
emptywheel @Thomas_Drake1 Phone dragnet was switching (USAF is part of) move to more automation. 12333 would be already. Do they not notice? @thegrugq
emptywheel I love how official photographers photograph Lynch w/her tall (Johnson) & taller (Comey) colleagues & manage height.
emptywheel RT @digiphile: On this #GivingTuesday, please consider registering to be an organ donor to give the gift of life:
emptywheel @lib_ertarian_ I don't think they have--they still want to save the Senate. They just can't control the monster they created.
emptywheel Shorter the entire GOP: The only thing that can save us from the monster we created is Hillary Clinton!
emptywheel The "Club for Growth" not growing.
emptywheel Great news! @onekade and I have not yet melded our brains which means we're twice as scary to the powers that be.
JimWhiteGNV The force is with the #Gators on Star Wars Night.
emptywheel RT @JasonLeopold: Good summary here: Interesting Tidbits from the House Intelligence Authorization via @emptywheel
December 2015
« Nov