Bigger Problem in US Than Ebola: Enterovirus D68 Spreading Respiratory, Paralytic Diseases in Children
It has now been five days since we learned that Thomas Duncan, who came to Dallas from Liberia, tested positive for Ebola. His condition has been downgraded to critical, but so far none of his contacts have come down with Ebola symptoms. Because those most likely to have been infected by him are now under close observation and have limited contact with others, it seems quite likely the disease will not spread in the US beyond the small handful of people under close monitoring.
By contrast, the US is in the midst of an ongoing outbreak of a virus that has put many children into intensive care units with severe respiratory illnesses. A handful of children in Colorado initially having respiratory illness have progressed to paralysis of some limbs and have tested positive for the virus. Four children who died from severe respiratory illness have tested positive for the virus but the CDC states that the role of the virus in these deaths is not yet known. Late yesterday, a medical examiner in New Jersey stated that the virus was the cause of death for a four year old boy.
The virus involved in this outbreak is Enterovirus D68. Background on the virology of enteroviruses in general can be found here, courtesy of Wong’s Virology online. There are five groups within the enterovirus genus. By far, the most well-known group is the one that comprises the polioviruses. Enterovirus D68 falls within the newest group of enteroviruses that are designated with numbers.
These are some of the smallest and simplest viruses known. The viral particle contains only a single piece of RNA. Inside the host cell, this RNA is turned into a single protein that then is capable of chopping itself into the four smaller proteins found on the viral coat. There is no membrane around the virus and the particles are stable at acid pH, so inactivation is best achieved with bleach or other disinfectants whose label say they are active against non-enveloped viruses.
The CDC released information on the outbreak on September 12, noting that hospitals in Kansas City and Chicago first alerted CDC to unusual numbers of children presenting with severe respiratory symptoms. The latest CDC information on the outbreak includes:
From mid-August to October 3, 2014, CDC or state public health laboratories have confirmed a total of 538 people in 43 states and the District of Columbia with respiratory illness caused by EV-D68.
The report continues:
EV-D68 has been detected in specimens from four* patients who died and had samples submitted for testing. The role that EV-D68 infection played in these deaths is unclear at this time; state and local health departments are continuing to investigate.
The difficulty for healthcare providers with this virus is that symptoms for those infected can range from very mild to severe. As also seen with poliovirus, only a small fraction of those infected get the most severe form of the disease. In the current outbreak, a very high proportion of the children with the worst respiratory symptoms already suffered from asthma:
Of the 19 patients from Kansas City in whom EV-D68 was confirmed, 10 (53%) were male, and ages ranged from 6 weeks to 16 years (median = 4 years). Thirteen patients (68%) had a previous history of asthma or wheezing, and six patients (32%) had no underlying respiratory illness.
Of the 11 patients from Chicago in whom EV-D68 was confirmed, nine patients were female, and ages ranged from 20 months to 15 years (median = 5 years). Eight patients (73%) had a previous history of asthma or wheezing.
Parents and school administrators are being encouraged to monitor children with asthma more closely during this outbreak and to be especially vigilant about measures to prevent spread.
Transmission of the virus, according to CDC:
You can get exposed to the virus by—
- having close contact, such as touching or shaking hands, with an infected person,
- touching objects or surfaces that have the virus on them,
- changing diapers of an infected person, or
- drinking water that has the virus in it.
If you then touch your eyes, nose, or mouth before washing your hands, you can get infected with the virus and become sick.
Of special concern is the outbreak of paralysis among children affected by the virus. From CNN last week:
Health officials are looking for the cause of a neurologic illness that’s affected 10 children in Colorado.
The children were hospitalized between August 9 and September 28 with muscle weakness in their limbs, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Something is affecting the children’s motor nerves, causing weakness primarily in their shoulders, triceps, biceps and hips, says Dr. Joyce Oleszek, a pediatric rehabilitation specialist at Children’s Hospital Colorado. Doctors are also seeing some weakness in the neck and facial muscles in these patients.
“It seems to be attacking the spinal cord and brain stem,” Oleszek said at a press conference Monday.
Tests of the children’s cerebrospinal fluid came back negative for enteroviruses and West Nile virus. But a test of their nasal passages found enterovirus in six out of eight patients who were tested.
The CNN story also notes that five similar cases were seen in California between August 2012 and July 2013.
CDC has described the Colorado cases more fully.
While health officials are watching asthma patients particularly closely for the worst respiratory effects of this virus, it should be noted that only two of the ten paralysis patients in Colorado had a history of asthma, so even though these children reported respiratory infections an average of a week before the onset of neurological symptoms, asthma history does not single out the patients at risk for neurological complications.
As with most virus infections, there are no known treatments for this virus and a vaccine has not been developed. That means that information from CDC about preventing exposure is relatively generic, as also seen in the graphic above.
Finally, there is a very interesting set of contrasts between Ebola and enteroviruses. Note from the information above that infection with enteroviruses is quite widespread and most cases are believed to be asymptomatic or to have only very mild symptoms. In contrast, Ebola patients almost all get extremely ill and a very high fraction of them die. Ebola, however, doesn’t spread nearly as easily as enteroviruses. This graphic from NPR illustrates that on average, one Ebola patient only infects two more patients while most other viral diseases result in more infections per infected person. We don’t have information on the number of others infected by each person infected with Enterovirus D68, but the closely related polioviruses produce 5 to 7 new infections resulting from each infected person.
No sign of infection among older adults? Is this a useful piece of information about the effect of this virus?
I’ve seen suggestions that the very low rate for adults is because they were exposed at younger ages and developed immunity.
Wonder if previous exposure to other similar enteroviruses confers a degree of partial immunity such that D68 infection in older adults might manifest as symptoms as mild as seasonal allergies? I heard so many complaints from adults about how bad the allergy season was this year, but the worst of ragweed pollen also happened about the same time as D68 was identified here in midwest. The spread of D68 may have been masked.
Also wonder if asthmatic/wheezing kids weren’t treated early because adults didn’t recognize symptoms as other than allergies or asthma aggravated by allergens.
Believe the spread of D68 is much wider than just these identified cases, not unlike swine flu’s spread in 2009. A middle-school age student was diagnosed with viral meningitis in our school district, for example, which is quite rare. But enteroviruses are a frequent underlying cause of viral meningitis. Is this youth an undiagnosed D68 patient, we might wonder?
“Bigger problem in U.S. than Ebola”
Famous last words…
There have been dozens of confirmed cases of D68. It’s easier to pass to someone else than Ebola. That’s the problem. While the media are whipping up a frenzy over a few people with a virus that, although frequently fatal, is difficult to pass to others, stuff like D68 (and flu – flu is a very dangerous virus) get under the radar.
Dude. Nobody’s been watching D68 the way they’ve been watching Ebola. I mean look at this: there are dead kids and paralyzed kids, all across the U.S., and they’re just watching. No vaccine in the offing, whatsoever.
But whisper ooga-booga-boo! EBOLA!! and everybody’s panicky. How many children dead of D68 do we need before the media and CDC get their act together about proportional attention and effective communication?
Our media are criminally complacent about this virus. And to think schools are emptying out in Dallas because of one ebola case! These kids are really sick — and probably some have died — and there’s no public health warnings. Why not?
No public health warnings? That’s an overstatement. There have been plenty of warnings to parents that this virus is virulent and that if your kid has asthma and contracts it that it can be deadly. There have definitely been warnings stating to be aware that respiratory distress is common enough for the under 17 set to consider getting medical attention should symptoms arise. Now have there been anything other than warnings? No. Then again, I get the impression that the vaccine we created for polio had some pretty bad side effects that include flaccid paralysis so the medical community may not be at the ready with a vaccine that doesn’t create new problems if introduced to children.
NONE. ZERO. NO WARNINGS.
I’ve got a kid in the K-12 public school system here in the midwest, and another in college in midwest. We’ve had ZERO warnings. NONE.
Unless students’ parents have been hanging out at the CDC’s site, there’s been no notification until news media began reporting on this.
By the time the media reported on D68, it was already too late for some families.
Part of the problem is that the horror of polio is now largely forgotten in the US. Keep in mind that the vaccines were introduced 60 years ago and universal immunization was pretty much done within 10 years after that. I remember getting my sugar cube when I was still a toddler – it’s one of my earliest memories. (I wanted another ’cause I liked sugar.) So, now we have a little-known, less-understood killer and paralytic disease running wild. OTOH, Ebola has benefitted in the 40 or so years since it first became known from books, movies, fictionalizations (usually involving someone rogue who weaponizes it), scary articles and very cinematic means of killing its victims. I mean, basically exploding from the inside out….
D68 just kills poor kids and cripples some – you can’t make movies about that.
Thankfully, NBC is featuring a segment about D68 right after their segment on Ebola this morning.
It should be noted that while this virus has until recently been rare in the United States, it has been endemic in Central America (Virology Journal, Garcia et al., 2013, 10:305).
The last year Obama has accepted many tens of thousands of illegal immigrant children from Central America, and spread them out in communities and schools across the United States without medical screening. Shortly after doing this, suddenly this virus crops up in American children across the country.
It would seem likely that the outbreak of this virus in the United States was created by recent immigration policy. This possibility could easily be dispelled by showing a lack of correlation between the disease outbreak sites and the places that the illegal immigrants have been enrolled in schools, yet such is not forthcoming. Instead, there is apparently a total ban on even suggesting this possibility.
It would be hard to screen for this virus, because it has not been commonly found here, but not impossible. Even if you think that this nation should accept the populations of Central America, it could have been done without risking the spread of disease. But that would have slowed the process down, and Obama and friends didn’t want to make the effort. Besides, their kids don’t rub elbows with illegal immigrants in low-class public schools.
Add to your comment the ongoing lack of affordable housing in California. How can a family rent a place at a normal rent when the landlord can rent the house to five Central American families willing and happy to cram into what was once a Middle Class home?
Then there is the lack of living wage jobs. You expect employers to pay a living wage to workers when they can get an unlimited number of near slaves willing to work weekends, holidays and long hours for little pay?
The virus has been here since the 60s and could be spread by anyone. I am so sick of hearing this is because of immigrants. It could just as easily be that the virus just decided that this was a good year to strike hard and it was an AMERICAN child that spread it(since there is NO freaking vaccine for the disease.)
I don’t blame them for not releasing data on those children. There are some real nutballs and releasing that data would be to TARGET them.
Who is the nutball? ” The virus just decided it was a good year to strike?” Yeah I’m sure it has a mind. LOL!
It’s an analogy about the likelihood of two scenarios, of which both were unlikely. Get it? The ad hominem isn’t helpful to the discussion.
It should be noted…spare me and do some homework instead of blaming immigration policies or the lack thereof.
Worldwide emergence of multiple clades of enterovirus 68
Rafal Tokarz, Cadhla Firth, Shabir A. Madhi, Stephen R. C. Howie, Winfred Wu,5 Amadou Alpha Sall, Saddef Haq, Thomas Briese, and W. Ian Lipkin
J Gen Virol. Sep 2012; 93(Pt 9): 1952–1958.
While you’re actually doing some research, check these:
— Detection of enterovirus 68 as one of the commonest types of enterovirus found in patients with acute respiratory tract infection in China. [J Med Microbiol. 2014]
— Acute respiratory infections due to enterovirus 68 in Yamagata, Japan between 2005 and 2010. [Microbiol Immunol. 2012]
— Enterovirus 68 in children with acute respiratory tract infections, Osaka, Japan. [Emerg Infect Dis. 2011]
— Enteroviruses as agents of emerging infectious diseases. [J Neurovirol. 2005]
In other words, EV-D68 1) was already present in clusters in the US, 2) could have been spread across globe using same vector as Ebola (air travel), 3) was a known problem OUTSIDE western hemisphere, and 4) was known to be an emergent threat for nine damned years.
You’re going to have to bring more than bigotry to explain the US gov’t’s relative inaction under two different administrations.
Regarding polio and there being no vaccine for Enterobacter D-68. Dr. Saulk did not patent his creation of a vaccine for polio. He said it belonged to the people. Its all about the money today.